To report any issues with the information below please email executivecycle@westberks.gov.uk.

Agenda item

2025/26 Performance Report Q4

To provide assurance that the priority areas in the Council Strategy 2023-2027 are being managed effectively as at the end of the 2025/26 year and, where performance has fallen below the expected level, present information on the remedial action taken and the impact of that action.

Minutes:

The Committee considered the Quarter 4 Performance Report for 2025/26 (Agenda Item 8).

Councillor Vic Poole (Portfolio Holder for Strategy and Governance, and Commercialisation) introduced the report, which would also be reviewed by the Executive on 2 July 2026.

Prior to opening the item up for questions, Councillor Poole explained that while she would provide an answer to as many questions as possible, it might prove necessary to provide answers in relation to other portfolios post the meeting.

Councillor Carolyne Culver noted that the target for the measure ‘go live with Grazeley Solar Farm’ showed as December 2025. She asked when this would be updated. Councillor Poole explained that the report retained the original target date. Any subsequent changes were outlined within the report commentary.

Councillor Antony Amirtharaj felt that greater clarity was needed in the report to explain why, in some cases, the year-end RAG rating was reported as ‘Green’, but the area of work appeared to still be in progress. Councillor Poole explained that an item would only be marked as completed when it was delivered. Until then, it would be reported as RAG. Some measures would continue to be tracked over a rolling period and would therefore remain live rather than becoming a completed project.

Councillor Ross Mackinnon noted that a number of ‘Red’ indicators were being reported, making specific reference to indicators within the Portfolio of Children and Family Services. He queried whether an action plan was in place in order to make improvements for ‘Red’ indicators and who was responsible for these.

Councillor Poole confirmed that individual officers were responsible for the various KPIs. She pointed out that stretched targets were in place as the Council strove to reach a higher standard than that required nationally or by comparator local authorities. While Councillor Mackinnon commended this ambition, he stated that performance in these areas still needed to be taken into account and scrutinised.

Councillor Poole noted that Councillor Mackinnon had submitted a question to the Leader of the Council for the Executive meeting on 2 July 2026 in relation to the mechanism for improving performance in areas rated as ‘Red’. It was therefore agreed that a fuller response would be provided at that meeting.

Councillor Culver queried progress in meeting the indicator for pothole repairs. She noted that Members had previously been told that West Berkshire had a green national rating for pothole repairs, however performance was rated as ‘Red’ in the report. She queried why this was the case when the national picture suggested that the authority was performing well in this area. Councillor Poole understood that the ‘Red’ status in the report was linked to a period during which adverse weather conditions had prevented repairs from being made within the required timeframe. The status of this measure was about delivery of particular repairs and was regardless of the positive external assessment of the standard of the Council’s total road network.

Sarah Clarke added that her understanding was the same as Councillor Poole. I.e. that severe weather had affected the Council’s ability to respond to the number of potholes within the required quarter, meaning that the indicator could not be recovered within the year-end reporting window. This was regardless of the fact that performance in subsequent quarters had returned to the planned target level.

Councillor Mackinnon returned to the discussion on the Grazeley Solar Farm and asked when the decision would be made on whether the scheme would proceed or not. Councillor Poole would direct this question to the relevant Portfolio Holder and ask them to provide a response to Councillor Mackinnon.

Councillor Mackinnon felt this highlighted the need for Portfolio Holders to be present at meetings in order to answer questions on the night.

RESOLVED that:

·       The progress made in delivering the Council Strategy Delivery Plan 2023-2027 be noted.

·       Those areas where performance was below target had been reviewed by the Committee and remedial action noted.

Supporting documents: