To report any issues with the information below please email executivecycle@westberks.gov.uk.

Agenda item

Called-in report - Planning Enforcement Plan 2026

To consider the call-in request to review the Executive decision to adopt the West Berkshire Council Planning Enforcement Plan 2026.

Minutes:

The Committee considered the report (Agenda Item 6b) which outlined the call-in request for the Committee to review the Executive decision of 11 June 2026 to adopt the Planning Enforcement Plan 2026.

Councillor Denise Gaines, Portfolio Holder for Planning and Housing, made the following points in support of the Executive’s decision:

·       An enforcement plan was not a statutory requirement, but it was a useful tool to guide enforcement investigations and ensure that actions taken were both consistent and transparent.

·       The plan had been refreshed and modified in order to update the priority classifications so that officer effort could be focused on the most significant breaches in a timelier way. Cases were prioritised into four categories:

  • Category 1 – Urgent Action: initial assessment within two working days, in cases where there was a risk of substantial and irreversible impacts on the environment and/or local community.
  • Category 2 – High priority: initial assessment within 15 working days, covering alleged breaches of planning control where there was a risk of significant impacts on the environment and/or significant public interest.
  • Category 3 – Standard priority: initial assessment within 40 working days, covering alleged breaches where there was a risk of planning harm, and likely to include the majority of cases, such as household developments, fences, walls and gates.
  • Category 4 – Low priority: over 40 working days or not expedient to investigate, covering the least harmful and lowest-level matters. The initial assessment would largely be desk-based.

Councillor Gaines stated that all cases would receive some level of investigation via the initial assessment. There would not be a case of permanent inaction as had been suggested in the reasons for call-in.

The following points were made by the call-in Members:

·       It was fully accepted that planning enforcement cases needed prioritisation when considering the enforcement workload and budget constraints. However, it was important to be transparent with residents on the timeframe for a case to be reviewed, particularly if it was assessed as being Category 4. An appropriate level of communication needed to take place with residents, including if the decision was made to not pursue a case.

·       There was concern that it was not specified whether Category 4 cases would receive an initial assessment and that some could be assessed as not being expedient to investigate. The desktop analysis might not be sufficiently thorough, particularly if mapping tools were not kept up to date.

·       This lower level response could result in residents not coming forward to report planning breaches and lead to further breaches.

·       The point was made that planning enforcement formed a major part of a Councillor’s casework.

·       It was not felt appropriate to have brought this item to an extraordinary Executive.

Councillor Gaines made the following points in response to those comments:

·       She reiterated that all reported matters would receive an initial assessment. This consideration provided a level of investigation and cases would be categorised from there. Councillor Gaines did not expect many cases to be Category 4.

·       She felt the revised plan provided a greater level of transparency and was more detailed than the version produced in 2022. It therefore provided a greater level of information for residents and outlined the different timescales for a response. This helped to address points made in the public consultation for a greater level of information, such as on timescales.

A number of points were then discussed in the debate and made in response to further questions.

Councillor Antony Amirtharaj agreed with the point that a significant proportion of a councillors’ casework involved helping residents with planning enforcement matters. He was pleased to note that the revised Enforcement Plan gave a greater level of clarity to residents on service expectations.

Councillor Amirtharaj praised the excellent job being done by the Council’s Enforcement Officers, but queried whether there would be adequate resources to meet the timescales in the Plan, particularly for higher category cases. He also highlighted the importance of keeping residents informed on actions to be taken and timescales following the initial assessment.

In response, Councillor Gaines explained that setting fixed timescales for subsequent action was difficult as the action required depended on the nature of the breach. However, further information could be accessed on an enforcement case on the planning portal. In terms of resource levels, a Compliance Officer had recently been appointed and a team manager was in post.

Councillor Eric Pattenden considered that the new strategy represented an improvement as it would enable the prioritisation of serious breaches and the response to them. He was supportive of the new Enforcement Plan.

Councillor Jeremy Cottam queried whether there would be instances where breaches were not investigated. Councillor Gaines replied that every case would receive an initial assessment. However, some Category 4 cases would not receive a fuller investigation if they did not constitute a breach or was not considered to constitute any harm. A case could however be recategorised if additional information came to light.

Councillor Carolyne Culver queried the inclusion of traffic hazards within Category 2 as she felt these should be treated with a greater level of urgency, while acknowledging that Highways could respond in advance of planning enforcement action. Councillor Gaines stated her expectation that if a breach created a danger to the public then it would likely be treated as a Category 1 matter.

Councillor Richard Somner asked whether the categorisation could be added to the planning portal in order to enhance the data available. Councillor Gaines felt this could be incorporated.

Councillor Mackinnon sought further clarification on those cases that would be assessed only and those that would be investigated. He felt this point lacked clarity, particularly for Category 4 matters.

Councillor Gaines replied that a desktop analysis would be conducted for all cases. She felt this initial assessment constituted a form of investigation. As already stated, a Category 4 case could be given a higher category and subject to a fuller investigation. Councillor Mackinnon felt this needed greater clarification within the Plan.

Laura Callan, Interim Service Director for Development and Housing, clarified that the intention behind Category 4 had been to capture very minor cases and, in some of those cases, it was the expectation that there would be no enforcement breach or a concern did not cause harm. The desktop assessment would be undertaken in all cases at the initial stage. She acknowledged that the wording could be updated to aid clarification and provide a clearer distinction between initial assessment and further investigation.

Councillor Mackinnon then proposed that the decision be referred back to the Executive for reconsideration. He proposed that the Committee should recommend that the Executive publish clear guidance to explain the planning enforcement categories and the service standards to be expected for each category. It should also be made clear as to what constituted an initial assessment and what constituted an investigation. The proposal was seconded by Councillor Somner.

The proposal was not approved by the Committee. It was therefore resolved that the decision of the Executive would stand.

Councillor Somner then queried if the wording of the Plan could be updated to aid clarification as had been discussed. Councillor Culver felt it would be appropriate to make this request of the Portfolio Holder. This was agreed by the Committee. Councillor Gaines agreed this would be considered.

RESOLVED that:

·       The Executive decision of 11 June 2026, to adopt the Planning Enforcement Plan 2026, would stand.

·       The Committee’s comments on the wording used in the Plan would be considered for inclusion by the Portfolio Holder. This included reference made to initial assessments and investigations, and information made available on the planning portal.

Supporting documents: