Agenda item
Called-in report: ID4816 - Section 19 Statement and Educational Neglect Policy Approval
To consider the call-in request to review the Individual Decision concerning the Section 19 Statement and Educational Neglect Policy.
Minutes:
The Committee considered the call in of the Individual Executive Member Decision (ID4816) on 11 June 2026 on the Section 19 Statement and Educational Neglect Policy Statement.
Since Councillor Dominic Boeck was one of the Members who had asked for the decision to be called in, he asked Councillor Owen Jeffery to chair the meeting during discussion of this item. (Councillor Jeffery assumed the chair.)
Councillor Heather Codling (Deputy Leader and Executive Portfolio Holder for Children and Family Services), and Ashley Milum (Service Director – Education) gave a summary of the policy and the reasons for its approval:
· It was explained that the policy had been developed to meet the Council’s legal duties, and to provide a clear framework for everyone working with children in West Berkshire.
· The policy focused on keeping children safe, supporting their education and keeping them in a mainstream school wherever possible.
· The aim was to make the right decision for each individual child and to work constructively with parents.
· The policy and associated statements were aligned with statutory guidance.
· Although the policy had not been coproduced due to its statutory nature, the Council regularly engaged with the Parent Carer Forum and was in contact with families about policy development and practice more broadly.
· Parents were thanked for taking the time to read the policy and provide feedback - changes had already been made in response to the feedback received, and a revised draft of the policy had been issued in the supplementary agenda pack.
Councillor Dominic Boeck presented the reasons for the decision being called-in and the proposed alternative course of action:
· Members considered that such an important policy should have been subjected to scrutiny prior to approval.
· Sufficient numbers of parents had raised concerns that Members believed the decision should be called in and the policy given proper scrutiny, so all parties had confidence in the final version.
· Although families had not been given an opportunity to help shape the initial policy, it had since been reviewed and amended, taking account of feedback received, which demonstrated the value of co-production and scrutiny,
· Co-production and scrutiny prior to approval would have represented a better use of everyone’s time and would have given parents greater confidence in the outcome.
· It was stressed that good scrutiny and co-production led to better decision making and better use of resources.
· The proposed alternative course of action was to take the revised version of the policy – incorporating any further changes requested by the Scrutiny Committee – back through the approval process.
Other Members who had submitted the call-in raised the following points:
- West Berkshire Council was seeking to improve educational attainment of disadvantaged children, which would require a seismic change, drawing on all available resources.
- While some individuals had been able to contribute to the policy, others had not, and it was suggested that everyone should have the chance to be involved.
- Members sought clarification as to whether the policy sought to change the point at which schools handed over responsibility for individual pupils to the local education authority.
- It was suggested that the Council could widen how it engaged with parents beyond the Parent Carer Forum.
- Members indicated that there may be opportunities to learn from Oxfordshire County Council, which had been cited by parents as a best practice exemplar in this area.
- It was suggested that bundling the different policies into a single document may have led to some confusion.
The following points were made in response:
· The policy sought to keep children safe and ensure a consistent approach across all schools/members of staff.
· It was acknowledged that scrutiny of policies prior to adoption was best practice, however there had been an urgent need to have something in place ahead of the next Area SEND Inspection in the autumn.
· Since the policy was based on Statutory Guidance, the advice from the Council’s Legal Team had been that it could be produced without the need for public engagement.
· All Council policies are kept under review in order to respond to changing circumstances.
· Feedback received had informed changes to the policy and Councillor Codling was happy for the revised policy to be brought back through the cycle for approval.
· The Council has a strong focus on improving outcomes amongst disadvantaged children and young people, with new structures being put in place from September to galvanise efforts towards this. The Service Director was due to bring a paper in October about this.
· Officers acknowledged the need to factor in scrutiny prior to future decisions being taken where feasible.
· The proposed framework would provide a better understanding of where the Section 19 threshold lay, and while it did not change the point at which the Council took responsibility for a pupil, it would help to ensure a more consistent application of approach.
· Engagement was channelled through the Parent Carer Forum in order to manage officer workload and maintain focus on meeting the needs of children and young people.
· Officers undertook to review the Oxfordshire County Council policy to see if there was anything they could learn from it.
· It was recognised that there had been some conflation caused by the bundling of the three policy statements, but this had been driven by the urgent need to have policy statements in place. It was felt that the amended version was clearer.
Actions:
· Correct the spelling errors in the policy.
· Review the Oxfordshire County Council policy to see if there was anything that could be learned from this.
The following points were raised in the debate:
· It was confirmed that the policy was aligned with DfE statutory guidance, it had also been informed by the practice review undertaken by Association of Education Welfare Managers, and it was aligned with similar policies of other local authorities.
· Members asked about how the policy would improve safeguarding and educational outcomes for vulnerable children. Officers confirmed that the policy was a core part of ensuring the safety of children and having consistent thresholds across all schools. It would reduce safeguarding risks and risks of children not being in receipt of a good education.
· Officers confirmed that the framework would deliver consistent and timely interventions for children at risk of educational neglect, and it defined the point at which thresholds would be met.
· There was a question about how the policy would be reviewed to ensure it remained effective. Officers stressed that while there was a commitment to seeking feedback and undertaking pre-decision scrutiny where possible, in this case, there had been a need to move at pace due to the impending Area SEND inspection.
· Although there had been no consultation/co-production on this particular policy, it had been informed by discussions at previous meetings and workshops, and discussions with the Parent Carer Forum.
· Officers cited examples of where co-production had been used to good effect (e.g., SEND reforms, and School Inclusion Plans).
· It was suggested that there were inherent risks associated with producing policies at pace. Officers noted that the DfE was putting pressure on the Council to move quickly, and that the Committee had also previously recognised the need for urgent action. The revised document was felt to better reflect the reality of what the Council was trying to achieve.
· Monitoring of the policy, once adopted, was recognised as important and it was noted that the proposed performance dashboard would include attendance data, which would help to show whether the policy was working as planned. It was noted that policies were iterative in nature, responding to learnings from implementation.
· It was confirmed that because the policy had been called in, it had not been adopted. This meant that there was not yet a consistent framework in place. Officers indicated that in the event of an Area SEND inspection, they would be able to point to the draft policy, and the changes that had already been made in response to feedback received. The intention was to bring the amended version forward for adoption as quickly as possible.
· Members reflected that the policy related to an area that was charged with emotion. It was felt that the statutory guidance and need to move at pace should not be blamed for weaknesses in the policy. Members welcomed the improvements to the policy and suggested that lessons should be learned.
· Officers were asked to what extent they had drawn on the policies of other local authorities. It was confirmed that the policy had been co-produced across a number of local authorities through the Association of Education Welfare Managers, drawing on best practice from across the sector.
· Members asked if the new policy would help to simplify things for parents seeking to navigate the SEND system. Officers recognised the challenges that parents faced. It was noted that the Government was consulting on Education Other Than At School (EOTAS) as part of the national SEND reforms. This recognised that an increasing number of parents were requesting EOTAS packages. It was felt that the SEND reforms would help to meet needs earlier and reduce the demand for statutory services. Locally, work was ongoing to improve the timeliness of Education Health and Care Plans (EHCPs). Officers also highlighted the Longitudinal Thematic Analysis produced by the Parent Carer Forum – an 18 month study of parent experience, which identified six themes where issues were encountered. Workshops had been held with parents and would continue, and officers were also keen to engage with young people.
· It was noted that the policy placed significant responsibility on schools and officers were asked if the Headteacher’s Forum had been consulted. It was explained that the Council engaged with schools through the Primary and Secondary Heads Associations. It was reiterated that the policy was about alignment with statutory guidance and ensuring a consistent approach across all schools.
· Concern was expressed about the governance implications of having discrepancies between an adopted policy and actual working practice, and Members asked what would happen if there was not an adopted policy in place. It was accepted that taking the amended version of the policy back through the approval process would result in a better policy. Although this would lead to delay and a temporary absence of local policy, the statutory guidance would be taken as the fall-back position.
· The need for co-production on future policies was highlighted - this was acknowledged and accepted by officers who indicated that they welcomed being held to account in this respect. Officers also indicated that they welcomed challenge and scrutiny on policies and decisions before they were approved.
· The Committee noted the following governance improvements:
o Development of the performance dashboard.
o The creation of a West Berkshire Safeguarding and Children’s Partnership, which would provide more focused oversight of safeguarding outcomes within the district. (One of their first tasks would be to look at the safeguarding of children not in education due to the additional risks facing these children.)
o The relationship with schools was being reset in order to deliver improved outcomes, particularly for disadvantaged pupils. Schools were being organised into clusters and school leaders were being held more closely to account.
o Establishment of an Education Improvement Partnership to provide additional scrutiny and oversight.
· Going forward, the Scrutiny Committee would be able to review any of the above changes to have assurance that they were working as planned.
Councillor Dominic Boeck proposed that the Committee agree to:
· Refer the decision back to Individual Executive Decision for further consideration, with the recommendation that the revised policy be approved as set out in the Supplementary Agenda.
· Recommend that consideration be given to future co-production with parents, carers and stakeholders where this would strengthen policy.
· Recommend that lessons be learned from this process, recognising that effective co-production and scrutiny before a decision is likely to lead to better policy, greater confidence amongst families, and more efficient use of officer time and Council Resources.
The proposal was seconded by Councillor Paul Dick.
At the vote, the motion was carried.
RESOLVED that the Committee agree to:
· Refer the decision back to Individual Executive Decision for further consideration, with the recommendation that the revised policy be approved as set out in the Supplementary Agenda.
· Recommend that consideration be given to future co-production with parents, carers and stakeholders where this would strengthen policy.
· Recommend that lessons be learned from this process, recognising that effective co-production and scrutiny before a decision is likely to lead to better policy, greater confidence amongst families, and more efficient use of officer time and Council Resources.
Supporting documents:
-
3a.1 Call-In ID4816 - CYP Scrutiny report (S19 Statement and Ed Neglect Policy Approval, item 15.
PDF 299 KB -
3a.2 Individual_Decision_Report_Update_01.05.26, item 15.
PDF 349 KB -
3a.3 Policy Statement for S19 MTS and EOTAS, item 15.
PDF 496 KB -
3a.4 Educational Neglect Policy Statement, item 15.
PDF 401 KB -
Briefing Note - Children's Scrutiny July 2026, item 15.
PDF 967 KB