Agenda item
26/00858/HOUSE 3 Blake Road Hermitage Thatcham RG18 9WN
|
Proposal: |
Loft conversion and insertion of rooflights. |
|
Location: |
3 Blake Road Hermitage Thatcham RG18 9WN |
|
Applicant: |
Mr and Mrs Tandon |
|
Recommendation: |
Approval |
Minutes:
1. The Committee considered a report (Agenda Item 4(3)) concerning Planning Application 26/00858/HOUSE in respect of loft conversion and insertion of rooflights at 3 Blake Road, Hermitage, Thatcham, RG18 9WN.
2. Mr Jake Brown introduced the report to Members, which took account of all the relevant policy considerations and other material planning considerations. In conclusion the report detailed that the proposal was acceptable in planning terms and officers recommended that the Development Manager be authorised to grant planning permission subject to the conditions outlined in the main and update reports.
3. The Chairman asked Mr Paul Goddard (Highways Development Control Team Leader) if he had any observations relating to the application.
· Mr Goddard advised that the property currently benefited from two off-street parking spaces. He explained that the dwelling had been approved in 2012, before the Council's current parking standards were adopted, and therefore did not meet the standards that would apply to a new, four-bedroom dwelling today.
· He noted that the loft conversion would increase the property from four to five bedrooms. However, Policy DM44 required larger dwellings to be assessed on an individual basis. Having considered the proposal, the Highway Authority did not consider that the addition of one bedroom would create a significant increase in parking demand or justify a refusal on highway grounds.
· While acknowledging concerns raised by local residents and Hermitage Parish Council regarding parking pressures in the area, he advised that there was insufficient evidence to demonstrate that the proposal would result in a severe highway impact. He therefore confirmed that the Local Highway Authority raised no objection to the application and considered that a refusal based solely on parking provision would be difficult to defend at appeal.
4. In accordance with the Council’s Constitution, Councillor Paul Dick, Parish Council representative, Ms Tracy Seymour and Mr Simon Brookes, objectors, Mr Yuvraj Tandon, applicant, and Councillor Heather Codling, Ward Member, addressed the Committee on this application.
Parish/Town Council Representation
5. Councillor Dick addressed the Committee by reading out a statement on behalf of Hermitage Parish Council. The full representation can be viewed here:
Western Area Planning Committee - Recording
Member Questions to the Parish/Town Council
6. Members did not have any questions of clarification.
Objector Representation
7. Ms Seymour addressed the Committee. The full representation can be viewed here:
Western Area Planning Committee - Recording
Member Questions to the Objector
8. Members asked questions of clarification and were given the following responses:
· Ms Seymour advised that the garage would be converted into habitable accommodation and connected to the house by a link corridor.
· Ms Seymour advised that no measurements had been provided but that the approved plans showed a reduction in the available parking area.
Applicant Representation
9. Mr Tandon addressed the Committee. The full representation can be viewed here:
Western Area Planning Committee - Recording
Member Questions to the Applicant
10. Members did not have any questions of clarification.
Ward Member Representation
11. Councillor Codling addressed the Committee. The full representation can be viewed here:
Western Area Planning Committee - Recording
Member Questions to the Ward Member
12. Members did not have any questions of clarification.
Member Questions to Officers
13. Members asked questions of clarification and were given the following responses:
· The approved plans showed two parking spaces that met the Council’s adopted standards of 2.4m by 4.8m.
· According to Policy DM44 houses exceeding the bedroom thresholds in the parking standards must be assessed on an individual basis. Officers believed that the increase from four to five bedrooms would not create sufficient parking pressure to justify refusal.
· No evidence had been identified to demonstrate a significant increase in parking demand and therefore no highway objection had been raised.
· The Committee could only determine the application before it and could not revisit the merits of the previously approved scheme.
· Any failure to build in accordance with approved plans would be a matter for Planning Enforcement and so concerns about possible departures from approved plans were not relevant to the determination of the current application.
Debate
14. Councillor Howard Woollaston opened the debate by noting that, taken in isolation, the proposal for six rooflights appeared relatively modest. However, he recognised that concerns remained regarding parking provision and the cumulative impact of development that had taken place or been approved at the property.
15. Councillor Adrian Abbs expressed concern about the increase in the size of the dwelling that would result from the loft conversion. He noted that Members had heard evidence regarding parking constraints and considered that moving from a four-bedroom property to a five-bedroom property could place additional pressure on parking provision. Referring to the discussion regarding parking standards, he observed that this represented a significant increase above the level of development anticipated by the Council's adopted parking policies
16. Councillor Tony Vickers stated that he had initially been minded to support the Officer’s recommendation. However, following the site visit and the discussion during the meeting, he remained concerned about the practical functioning of the parking arrangements. He referred to the approved garage conversion scheme and questioned whether the parking spaces would be capable of being used comfortably in practice. He also noted that Hermitage was a location where many residents relied on private cars and therefore parking standards were particularly important. Despite those concerns, he acknowledged that the parking impacts identified might not be sufficient to sustain a refusal at appeal.
17. Councillor Martin Colston emphasised that the Committee could only determine the application before it, namely the insertion of six rooflights. While he understood the concerns regarding the approved garage conversion, he accepted the Officer’s advice that the Committee could not revisit or redetermine that separate planning permission. On that basis, he considered there were insufficient planning grounds to justify refusal.
18. Councillor Denise Gaines agreed with the points raised by Councillor Colston. She noted that the Committee was only being asked to consider the rooflights and that the associated internal loft conversion works would not themselves require planning permission. She further observed that had permitted development rights not previously been removed from the property, the rooflights may not have required a planning application at all. She therefore saw little justification for departing from the Officer’s recommendation.
19. Councillor Paul Dick referred to comments made during the site visit regarding future building works and potential deviations from approved plans. He noted that concerns of that nature would be matters for Planning Enforcement rather than for the determination of the current application. While he appreciated local concerns, he considered that the Committee should focus on the planning merits of the proposal before it.
20. Councillor Gaines proposed to accept Officer’s recommendation and grant planning permission subject to the conditions listed in the main report and update report. This was seconded by Councillor Woollaston.
21. The Chairman invited Members of the Committee to vote on the proposal by Councillor Gaines, seconded by Councillor Woollaston to grant planning permission. At the vote the motion was carried.
RESOLVED that the Development Manager be authorised to grant planning permission subject to the conditions listed in the main report and update report.
Supporting documents:
-
3a. 26.00858 3 Blake Road, item 3.(3)
PDF 239 KB -
3b. 2600858HOUSE 3 Blake Road MAP, item 3.(3)
PDF 95 KB -
3. 2600858HOUSE 3 Blake Road Hermitage, item 3.(3)
PDF 154 KB