Agenda item
Application No. and Location: 25/01915/FULMAJ at Padworth Saw Mills, Rag Hill, Aldermaston, Reading, RG7 4NU
|
Proposal: |
Part retrospective: Retention of storage shed, entrance gates, hard surfacing and boundary treatments (including gabion walls, security railings, and mesh fencing), as well as the marginal extension of boundary treatments and additional hard surfacing. Change of Use to B8 storage and Distribution. |
|
Location: |
Padworth Saw Mills, Rag Hill, Aldermaston, Reading, RG7 4NU |
|
Applicant: |
Mr P Harrington |
|
Recommendation: |
To delegate to the Development Manager to GRANT PLANNING PERMISSION |
Minutes:
- Before discussing this item, there was a brief adjournment at 8.15pm in order to facilitate a comfort break. The meeting reconvened at 8.25pm.
- Continuation of the meeting: During consideration of this item, the time approach 10pm. In accordance with the Council’s Constitution point 7.13.5, the Committee supported the Chairman’s motion, seconded by Councillor Ross Mackinnon, that the remaining business could be concluded by 10.30pm, and therefore that the Committee would continue with Agenda Item 4(2).
- The Committee considered a report (Agenda Item 4(2)) concerning Planning Application 25/01915/FULMAJ in respect of the proposed retention and marginal extension of boundary treatments at Padworth Saw Mills, Aldermaston.
- The Planning Officer, Sian Cutts, introduced the report to Members, which took account of all the relevant policy considerations and other material planning considerations. In conclusion the report detailed that the proposal was acceptable in planning terms and officers recommended that the Head of Planning and Development be authorised to grant planning permission, subject to the conditions outlined in the main and update reports.
- The Chairman asked the Highways Officer, Paul Goddard, if he had any observations on the application. He highlighted that:
28.1 That the site had a complicated history but that it was in commercial use for decades and always enjoyed access onto Rag Hill – a single carriageway through much of its length in proximity to the site. There were signs displayed when leaving the site directing traffic to turn left only, going south. The intention was that these signs would remain if the application was approved.
28.2 The applicant’s traffic consultant’s report used standard methodology to predict traffic movements for B2 and B8 uses, finding that B8 produced less traffic due to the nature of the activities permitted. The Council also produced their own assessment, which also indicated a reduction in traffic from the proposed change of use. Therefore, if the application was approved, it was predicted that there could be better traffic flows onto Rag Hill.
28.3 Due to this prediction, and that Highways had no objections to the other changes on the site, they registered no objection overall to the proposal.
- In accordance with the Council’s Constitution, Desmon Farndell, Aldermaston Parish Council representative, Rob Smith, objector, and Haydon Richardson, agent, addressed the Committee on this application.
Parish Council Representation
- Desmon Farndell addressed the Committee. This representation can be viewed on the recording: Eastern Area Planning Committee – 2 September 2026.
Member Questions to the Parish Council
31. Members did not have any questions of clarification.
Objector Representation
32. Rob Smith addressed the Committee virtually. This representation can be viewed on the recording: Eastern Area Planning Committee – 2 September 2026.
Member Questions to the Objector
33. Members asked questions of clarification and were given the following responses:
33.1 That the use of generators on the site was not considered a nuisance, but that it was not environmentally sustainable. However, he did believe that some complaints about the site had been submitted to the Council.
Agent Representation
34. Haydon Richardson addressed the Committee. This representation can be viewed in the recording: Eastern Area Planning Committee – 2 September 2026.
Member Questions to the Agent
35. Members asked questions of clarification and were given the following responses:
35.1 That all B2 use activities had been discontinued. These had been a car garage, recycle and waste centre, and scaffolding activities. Any HGV or other related traffic currently coming to and from the site would only relate to B8 activities.
35.2 That additional tree planting beyond what was suggested would not be ideal given the applicants desire for the site to be used for B8 activities. However, the trees that had already been removed had been unprotected.
35.3 That the current owner had taken control of the site in 2022.
Ward Member Representation
36. Councillor Dominic Boeck addressed the Committee. This representation can be viewed in the recording: Eastern Area Planning Committee – 2 September 2026
Member Questions to the Ward Member
37. Members asked questions of clarification of Councillor Boeck and were given the following responses:
37.1 That the gable wall and fencing proposed would not be in keeping with the local area.
37.2 That conditions on the potential approval of the application had not been considered, although they were mentioned by the Parish Council.
Member Questions to Officers
38. Members asked questions of clarification and were given the following responses:
38.1 The site itself had lawful use of B2 activities and associated storage, due to the approved sawmill, as well as B8 activities in several areas. The application would remove these and grant a general B8 use across the whole of the site.
38.2 That limits on the hours of use and over lighting could be added via conditions. However, overly prescriptive conditions, such as over the type of material stored, was not appropriate. If there was concern about the types of material stored due to the site falling within a rural area, then the Committee could refuse the application on those grounds.
38.3 Environmental Health issued no objections to the application.
38.4 That B8 storage tends to allow the storage of materials, not vehicles, and that lorry storage was typically sui generis.
38.5 That there had been no traffic incident report in the period 2015-24.
38.6 Although unauthorised uses did not turn countryside into developed land, it was suggested that the site was physically related to its existing uses.
38.7 That there was nothing to prevent the applicant intensifying the B8 activities on the site following permission.
38.8 That the traffic movement prediction was based on B8 uses per 100 square metres, not a situation where the whole of the site was in B8 use.
38.9 That the left turn (south) of exiting traffic onto Rag Hill was put in place as turning right (north) was even more unsuitable for HGVs.
38.10 That a recent change to the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF) has somewhat superseded Local Plan Policy SP17, the strategic approach to employment land.
38.11 That, due to the approved sawmill and ancillary storage yard, Officers believed that the site constituted B2 usage.
38.12 That Officers could not confirm what percentage of the site was being used for B2 and ancillary activities and what was being used for B8.
38.13 That the ground levels would not be altered as they are not part of the application and likely were changed beyond the scope of potential planning enforcement interventions – over ten years without challenge.
Debate
39. Councillor Paul Kander opened the debate by indicating that he did not believe that the Committee had enough information to make an informed decision on the application. As the site could see B8 intensification across the entire site, traffic predictions should cover the whole area. In addition, Members would benefit from a map overlaying the area of existing B2 and B8 uses, and then the proposed B8 area.
40. Councillor Ross Mackinnon also indicated that he did not feel like there was enough information in the documentation about how much of the current site was used for B2 and B8 uses. Therefore, he did not believe the traffic assessment could be accurate.
41. In response to the points made about a lack of information, the Development Management Team Leader indicated that it would be difficult to get more clarity. If the Committee considered that there was not sufficient information to demonstrate that the entire site had lawful B2 use or the approval could lead to an increase in vehicle movements, then they could refuse it on those grounds.
42. Councillor Nick Carter indicated that some of the issues raised with the application could be controlled via condition, such as on hours of delivery of materials.
43. Councillor Ross Mackinnon did not want to move past the previous issues with the site, specifically highlighting that there was more scope for increased landscaping. It was also emphasised that the Council could regularise the use of activities on the site through enforcement. Overall, as the application could lead to the intensification of activity on the site, the damage could outweigh the benefits of a blanket B8 use.
44. Councillor Justin Pemberton indicated that he did not believe there was enough time in the debate to cover every aspect of the application. He specifically raised the economic implications, noting the importance of sustaining the rural economy in the NPPF, that were not previously mentioned in detail.
45. Councillor Ross Mackinnon proposed to reject Officer’s recommendation and refuse the change of use application for the reasons listed below. This was seconded by Councillor Chris Read.
46. At the vote the motion was carried.
RESOLVED that the Development Manager be authorised to refuse the change of use application for the following reasons:
That the Committee were not satisfied that it had been sufficiently demonstrated that the entire site had been in previous B2 use when used in association with the sawmill, and that therefore a B8 use across the entire application site would result in an intensification of use from the previously authorised use of the site for sawmill and ancillary storage. This would lead to a potential significant increase in associated vehicle movements beyond the previous authorised uses on the site. The associated unauthorised works on site, resulting in loss of trees and an increase in vehicle movements has resulted in harm to the character and appearance of Raghill, and the erosion of its rural character, that outweighs the economic benefits of the proposed B8 use. This is compounded by the minimal landscaping proposals that would not sufficiently mitigate the associated visual harm from the intensification of use of the site, particularly in views from the adjacent highway.
This is contrary to Policy SP17, DM35 and DM25 of the West Berkshire Local Plan 2023-2041 and Policy E4 (2), and TR6(4) of the NPPF which says development proposals should be of a high quality design and in keeping with the surrounding environment, that requires that the use is suitable for the rural location and will not generate traffic of a type or amount inappropriate for the rural roads, and for development to be appropriate it terms of character and appearance of the rural area and setting in the landscape, and fails to provide sufficient compensation for the loss of trees in this rural lane.
Supporting documents:
-
02. 25_01915_FULMAJ Padworth Saw Mills, item 4.(2)
PDF 421 KB -
02a Appendix to Padworth Sawmill Report Plan from 1994 permission, item 4.(2)
PDF 619 KB -
02b. 25_01915_FULMAJ Map, item 4.(2)
PDF 322 KB -
02c. 25_01915_FULMAJ Full Plans (Compressed), item 4.(2)
PDF 5 MB -
00. Update Front Page, item 4.(2)
PDF 85 KB -
02. 25_01915_FULMAJ Update, item 4.(2)
PDF 249 KB -
02. Appendix to 25-01915-FULMAJ 2220853-Appeal Decision -Woodstock Paices Hill, item 4.(2)
PDF 216 KB