Agenda item
Deficit Schools (Mollie McQuade)
Minutes:
Mollie McQuade introduced the report (Agenda Item 14) and advised that 17 maintained schools were currently budgeting for a deficit position, with a combined deficit of £1.7m.
Brett Melville-Smith referred to previous discussion regarding the relationship between school deficits, surplus places and pupil numbers across West Berkshire. He queried the extent to which the number of schools in deficit reflected individual school budget management, as opposed to wider structural issues arising from surplus school places. Ashley Milum advised that there was some correlation between surplus places and financial pressures, but the relationship was not straightforward. He noted that some schools with surplus places remained financially sustainable, whilst others without significant surplus places were experiencing budget deficits. He explained that officers were working with schools to ensure expenditure was as effective and efficient as possible, including the use of Integrated Curriculum and Financial Planning tools to benchmark spending and support financial planning.
Councillor Heather Codling added that feedback received through the recent consultation process was still being reviewed and that a response would be provided in due course. She recognised the significant financial pressures facing schools and agreed that schools experiencing financial difficulties were not always those with lower numbers of pupils. She noted that, whilst surplus places formed part of the picture, some solutions could involve measures such as reducing Published Admission Numbers (PAN). She added that uncertainty surrounding local government reorganisation further complicated the position and that further information would be brought back once available.
Jo MacArthur referred to the factors affecting deficit recovery identified within the report and queried what support was available to schools and headteachers to address these issues and what action was taken where deficits arose for these reasons. Ashley Milum advised that officers had been considering this issue and recognised that there was an opportunity to provide greater support to schools approaching a deficit position. Mollie McQuade added that the Finance Team was reviewing its processes for managing deficit budgets, including escalation arrangements and regular monitoring of deficit positions. She advised that officers were working with schools to identify opportunities for improvement and that this work would be aligned with wider school improvement and school sufficiency processes.
Jo MacArthur commented that there was also an opportunity to learn from schools which had remained financially sustainable, including those with surplus places. She suggested that good practice should be identified and shared to support schools before they reached a deficit position.
Rebecca Hartley sought assurance that sufficient capacity existed within the Finance Team to support schools in deficit, noting that the officer previously responsible for this work had left the authority and expressing concern about the support currently available to schools. Mollie McQuade advised that recruitment to the vacant post was underway and that a revised deficit management process was being developed to strengthen budget monitoring, recovery planning and escalation arrangements.
Rebecca Hartley acknowledged the proposed process but remained concerned about the current capacity within the team to deliver that support. Rebecca Hartley further queried whether there was any emerging national direction regarding options such as school closures, federation or academisation in response to increasing numbers of schools forecasting budget deficits. Ashley Milum advised that he was not aware of any national direction on this issue. He explained that officers intended to continue discussions with schools through cluster arrangements and explore opportunities to share learning and best practice across the area. He noted that discussions with governors had included consideration of options such as federation where appropriate and that the Local Authority's (LA) role was largely one of facilitating local conversations. Ashley Milum added that officers were also engaging with other local authorities facing similar pressures to understand how they were responding to these challenges. It was acknowledged that there was no straightforward solution.
Reverend Mark Bennett expressed concern about the capacity available to support schools facing financial pressures. He queried what work was being undertaken to identify schools at risk of deficit in future and suggested that schools may require additional support when considering measures such as reducing PAN or merging classes. He also queried whether financial pressures were having an impact on work to support disadvantaged pupils. Mollie McQuade advised that officers were reviewing historical trends to identify schools that may be at risk of falling into deficit. Ashley Milum advised that the encouragement to schools was to take decisions before reaching a deficit position and noted that measures such as reducing PAN and reorganising classes, whilst difficult, may need to be considered. He explained that such decisions rested with schools and governors supported by information available to them, with the Local Authority providing checks and balances and support where required.
In relation to disadvantaged pupils, Ashley Milum advised that outcomes for disadvantaged learners remained a local concern. He reported that an audit programme was underway to review the use of Pupil Premium funding across a sample of schools and assess whether funding was being used effectively to support disadvantaged pupils.
Gary Norman suggested that future reports include additional contextual information alongside the deficit figures, such as school size and pupil characteristics, to assist Schools' Forum in understanding and comparing the data presented. Mollie McQuade agreed that this information could be included in future reports.
Brett Melville-Smith queried the expectation placed on schools that were unable to achieve a balanced budget within the three-year recovery period, despite having already reduced expenditure as far as reasonably possible. He also sought clarification on the Council's longer-term strategy for school place planning and financial sustainability and queried when Schools' Forum would have an opportunity to scrutinise this work. Ashley Milum advised that the Scheme for Financing Schools set out the expectations regarding recovery plans. He explained that where a school reached the point at which recovery was no longer considered achievable, a decision point would be reached and officers would make recommendations for political consideration as part of the wider work relating to school place planning.
Councillor Heather Codling advised that work on the strategy was ongoing and would consider school sufficiency across both maintained schools and academies. She noted that the LA was working as quickly as possible to develop the strategy but emphasised that the matter was complex. Councillor Codling commented that decisions regarding school sustainability were not straightforward and that it was not simply a case of identifying individual schools for closure.
Brett Melville-Smith acknowledged the sensitivities involved but expressed concern that delaying difficult decisions could have implications for educational outcomes. Councillor Codling agreed that children should remain at the heart of decision making. She acknowledged the desire to progress the work as quickly as possible but noted that such matters could take time to work through.
Councillor Iain Cottingham agreed that the primary consideration should be what was best for children and young people in West Berkshire and their outcomes. He noted that decisions regarding school sustainability were not straightforward and that wider factors, including demographic changes, future housing growth and the importance of rural communities, would need to be considered. He added that any decisions regarding school closures would have significant long-term consequences and therefore required careful consideration.
Chris Prosser commented that he had been encouraged by the small schools consultation, which had set out a clear way forward. He felt it would be helpful for schools to have greater clarity on the timescales for the next stages of the process, given the uncertainty facing small schools. Councillor Codling advised that work was continuing and that officers were working to progress the next stages. However, she explained that she was not currently in a position to provide a timetable for implementation.
Chris Prosser queried whether further information could be brought to the next Schools' Forum meeting. Councillor Codling advised that she would seek to provide an update as soon as possible but could not guarantee that it would be available for the next meeting.
The Vice Chair noted that public discussion of individual schools could have unintended consequences, particularly where concerns regarding a school's future might influence parental decisions. Councillor Codling agreed and explained that identifying individual schools publicly could have a detrimental impact, even where no decision had been made. Chris Prosser clarified that he was not seeking information on individual schools, but rather greater clarity regarding the overall process and anticipated timescales. He stressed that schools needed certainty and therefore felt it would be helpful if this information could be provided in time for the next Forum meeting. Councillor Codling noted the points raised.
RESOLVED that
- Future deficit school reports include additional contextual information, where available, to assist Schools' Forum in considering the data.
- Further information on the next stages of the small schools work and anticipated timescales be provided to Schools' Forum when available.</AI13>
Supporting documents: