Agenda item
Notices of Motion
To receive any Motions submitted in accordance with the Council Procedure Rules contained in the Council's Constitution.
Minutes:
Council received three Motions on notice.
As the first Motion had been discussed previously, Council considered the second, under-mentioned, Motion (of which Agenda Item 12(b) refers) submitted in the name of Councillor Carolyne Culver relating to ‘Cool Spaces for Summer 2027’.
MOTION: Proposed by Councillor Carolyne Culver and seconded by Councillor David Marsh:
That the Council:
“Cool Spaces for Summer 2027
Council notes:
· There were several heat waves in 2026, resulting in unnecessary excess deaths. This trend is likely to continue in the future.
· During the cost-of-living crisis several ‘warm spaces’ were established across the district.
· Many of these warm spaces have evolved into community cafes which continue to operate to this day.
· Based on UK Health Security Agency advice, WBC issues alerts and comprehensive advice to Members and residents during periods of excessive heat or cold.
Council resolves to request that the Executive:
1. Investigate the establishment of ‘cool spaces’ across West Berkshire in preparation for summer 2027.
2. Identify council owned properties that could be made available and which can be advertised as cool spaces during periods of extreme heat, subject to operational feasibility and available resources.
3. Work proactively with stakeholders across the district to identify spaces that they own, manage or hire, which the council could help advertise as cool spaces.
4. Consider how existing Council communication channels can be used to widely advertise these cool spaces to the public.
5. Report back to the Executive and Members on the proposed arrangements before 1 May 2027.”
Councillor Culver introduced the motion and highlighted that, a few years ago, warm spaces were established in the winter to help with the cost-of-living crisis. This motion focused on attempting to establish something similar in order to address the excess deaths that would result from the hot weather during the upcoming summers. Heat alerts were valuable to residents, but homes in the United Kingdom were not designed to deal with long hot spells, and so, many lived in homes that were intolerable in periods of significant heat. It was also highlighted that summer 2027 could be exceptionally hot due to the developing El Niño and so these spaces would be very valuable.
Some examples of cool spaces could be churches, such as St John’s in Wash Common, community facilities, and libraries. Having the Council put a list together would encourage residents to go to these facilities whereas they might have previously felt uncomfortable doing so. The Motion was also clarified, as it was proposing the Council identify and publicise existing cool spaces, not invest in the creation of new ones.
Council noted that the past heatwaves had highlighted inequalities in housing, as wealthier residents had installed more costly cooling measures, like air conditioning, whereas poorer households had no ability to properly cool their homes.
It was emphasised that the financial situation of the Council would limit the ability to invest officer resources in developing and implementing the proposal. However, Members argued that the Council should take leadership on the issue.
In addition, the potential role of parish and town councils in promoting the scheme was raised as a cost minimal action, and the encouraging of businesses to invest in overhead sails across the Highstreet to create a wider public cooling effect was also mentioned. Members could also highlight potential cool spaces in their wards to help officers with the identification process.
Overall, as Council was satisfied with the Motion, they agreed to approve it as proposed.
The Motion was put to the vote and declared RESOLVED.
Continuation of meeting: Proposed by Councillor Stephanie Steevenson and Seconded by Councillor Stuart Gourley.
RESOLVED: In accordance with the Council’s Constitution, Part 3, point 10.8, the Council supported the motion that the remaining business could be concluded by 10.30pm, and therefore that the meeting would proceed with the agenda item.
The Council considered the third, under-mentioned, Motion (of which Agenda Item 12(c) refers) submitted in the name of Councillor Carolyne Culver relating to ‘Questions at Scrutiny’.
MOTION: Proposed by Councillor Carolyne Culver and seconded by Councillor Richard Somner:
That the Council:
“Questions at Scrutiny
Council notes:
· 30 minutes is allocated for public questions at Council and Executive.
· Members of the public are allowed to submit questions to the new Highways Improvement Group.
· There is no provision for a public questions agenda item at our scrutiny meetings. Currently we must suspend standing orders to allow members of the public to speak.
· Many other councils allow a public questions agenda item at their scrutiny meetings.
Council resolves:
1. To allow time for a public questions agenda item at scrutiny meetings.
2. Public questions must relate to the meeting’s agenda items or the committee’s work programme, to ensure that the relevant Members and officers are on hand to respond.
3. That the relevant Members and officers consult with the three chairs of scrutiny about the details of how this can be implemented.”
Councillor Culver introduced the motion and highlighted that it would allocate time for agenda related questions at the three Scrutiny Committees of Council. Currently, if public were to speak at the meeting, the Chairman would need to suspend standing orders. This was not seen as very open and so the proposal would be likely be welcomed by residents and put the Council in line with other authorities around the country.
Councillor Vic Poole, as the relevant Portfolio Holder, spoke to the Motion and ensured Council that it would go through the proper internal governance processes.
The Chairman informed Council that the Motion would not be debated at this meeting. In accordance with Procedure Rule 12.6.2, the Motion would be referred to the Constitution Review Task Group. This would enable their input and that of expert Officers, before then coming back to Council for debate.
Supporting documents: