Agenda item
Planning Constitution Amendments - National Scheme of Delegations
This report asks Council to approve amendments to the Council’s Constitution to:
a) Implement the National Scheme of Delegation for planning functions, as introduced under the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 and given effect by the Town and Country Planning (Discharge of Local Planning Authority Functions) (England) Regulations 2026.
b) Establish a single Planning Committee to replace District Planning Committee, Eastern Area Planning Committee and Western Area Planning Committee.
c) Implement other minor amendments to the Constitution relating to Planning.
Minutes:
Councillor Denise Gaines (Executive Portfolio Holder – Planning and Housing) and Bob Dray (Interim Service Lead – Planning) presented the proposed Planning Constitution Amendments (Agenda Item 6).
The following points were raised in the debate:
· It was confirmed that there had been no feedback from the Constitution Review Task Group regarding the proposed amendments.
· There was a question about whether officers and Members would have sufficient guidance and training to minimise the risk of legal challenges around the interpretation and application of the gateway tests. Officers explained that one of the tests for an application to be referred to committee was around the significance of the application. This was a matter of planning judgement, which was why an experienced planning officer would be involved. Statutory guidance provided examples of how to interpret the tests. There would be regular meetings between the nominated Member and officer, with a legal advisor present until all parties were familiar with the process. A proforma was being developed, which would contain relevant questions/prompts and would also act as a record of the decision as to why each application was referred to committee or not.
· Officers were asked how the anticipated efficiencies of going from three planning committees to one would be measured. It was confirmed that the main measure would be the number of applications going to committee, which would be extracted from back office systems, with a Power BI dashboard providing live data.
· It was noted that under current arrangements, District Planning Committee only met when applications were referred up from one of the Area Planning Committees. Also, there was a significant imbalance in the number of applications being considered by the two Area Planning Committees. Moving to a single committee should reduce the number of meetings that had to be cancelled due to a lack of applications.
· Members asked about what weight would be given to letters from residents in relation to particular planning applications. It was explained that the number of letters received was not a material planning consideration - what mattered was the content of those letters.
· It was noted that ‘Member flagging’ would replace the current call-in system. However, this would only be used to ‘flag’ the application to the nominated Member and officer for consideration. An online form was being developed for this purpose, with supporting guidance to explain the legal tests.
· Clarification was sought as to whether Ward Members would be expected to submit letters of support/objection under the new system. It was confirmed that they would be able to make representations in the same way as anyone else.
· Officers were asked what measures would be put in place to ensure that triage and gateway test processes for Schedule 2 applications were transparent and robust. It was explained that there was a requirement for every decision of the nominated Member and officer to be recorded – these would be included in the officer’s report. Back office systems were due to be updated to pull this information to the front-facing website.
· Members asked how the Planning Service would monitor and report on whether applications that raised significant local issues were being filtered out from committee consideration. It was confirmed that Power BI dashboards would facilitate monitoring and review.
· It was suggested that other local authorities with a single planning committee be approached to understand what feedback they had received from Members. Officers stressed that the proposal was based on knowledge of past workload. A review of other local authorities with multi-area committees had been carried out and found that many were considering going down to a single committee.
· Clarification was sought as to what might happen if West Berkshire Council chose not to accept the reforms. Officers explained that the Council would have a cohort of applications which the current Constitution directed should go to committee. However, this would not be permitted under law, so a backlog of applications would build up, which would affect wider service delivery. Applicants would be able to appeal against non-determination, leading to legal challenges, appeals and associated costs, as well as reputational harm. It was stressed that the changes were legal requirements and were not optional.
· Members asked about the composition of the new Planning Committee. It was confirmed that this would be comprised of 11 Members and would reflect the political makeup of the Council. No recommendations had been made as to the geographical makeup of the Committee – this would be up to each political group. A report would go to Council allocating seats to the new Planning Committee alongside this report. It was not proposed to change allocations to other committees at this point.
· Officers were asked if they had sufficient staff resources to process all the applications. It was noted that it was more resource-intensive to bring an application to committee, so there should be less call on staff resources under the new system.
· It was suggested that the changes be clearly communicated to town/parish councils. Officers indicated that an email would be sent out and the matter would be discussed at the next District Parish Conference.
RESOLVED to:
a) Replace Section 8 (Service Director – Development and Housing) of the Scheme of Delegation in Part 11 of the Constitution with the changes shown in Appendix A to implement the National Scheme of Delegation and ensure the amended Constitution is in accordance with the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 and the Town and Country Planning (Discharge of Local Planning Authority Functions) (England) Regulations 2026.
b) Amend Part 6.8 Appendix Planning Committees with the changes shown in Appendix B to replace the existing three committee structure with a single Planning committee.
c) Delegate to the Monitoring Officer to make any minor substantive changes to the Constitution they deem necessary to ensure the Council’s planning delegation arrangement comply with the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 and the Town and Country Planning (Discharge of Local Planning Authority Functions) (England) Regulations 2026. This delegated authority is provided that any such changes are the minimum necessary to ensure compliance, and subject to the amendments being ratified by Full Council as soon as practicable.
d) Endorse a review of the new arrangements by the Service Lead for responsibility for planning between 6 and 12 months following implementation.
Supporting documents:
-
6. Planning Committees and National Scheme of Delegation - ARC 29-09-2026, item 24.
PDF 441 KB -
6a. Appendix A - Planning Scheme of Delegation, item 24.
PDF 222 KB -
6b. Appendix B - Planning Committee Appendix, item 24.
PDF 199 KB -
6c. Appendix C - Government Statutory Guidance, item 24.
PDF 232 KB -
6d. Appendix D - PAS Briefing Note, item 24.
PDF 601 KB -
6e. Appendix E - Existing Planning Committee Arrangements (14-09-2026), item 24.
PDF 205 KB