To report any issues with the information below please email executivecycle@westberks.gov.uk.

Agenda item

Planning Committee and National Scheme of Delegation

Purpose: To approve amendments to the Council’s Constitution to: a) Implement the National Scheme of Delegation for planning functions, as introduced under the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 and given effect by the Town and Country Planning (Discharge of Local Planning Authority Functions) (England) Regulations 2026; b) Establish a single Planning Committee to replace District Planning Committee, Eastern Area Planning Committee and Western Area Planning Committee; and c) Implement other minor amendments to the Constitution relating to Planning.

 

Minutes:

The Council considered a report (Agenda Item 10) concerning the changes to the Council’s Planning Committees following the National Scheme of Delegation.

MOTION: Proposed by Councillor Denise Gaines and seconded by Councillor Alan Macro:

That the Council:

1)    “Replace Section 8 (Service Director – Development and Housing) of the Scheme of Delegation in Part 11 of the Constitution with the changes shown in Appendix A to implement the National Scheme of Delegation and ensure the amended Constitution is in accordance with the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 and the Town and Country Planning (Discharge of Local Planning Authority Functions) (England) Regulations 2026.

2)    Amend Part 6.8 Appendix Planning Committees with the changes shown in Appendix B to replace the existing three committee structure with a single Planning committee.

3)    Delegate to the Monitoring Officer to make any minor substantive changes to the Constitution they deem necessary to ensure the Council’s planning delegation arrangement comply with the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 and the Town and Country Planning (Discharge of Local Planning Authority Functions) (England) Regulations 2026. This delegated authority is provided that any such changes are the minimum necessary to ensure compliance, and subject to the amendments being ratified by Full Council as soon as practicable.

4)    Endorse a review of the new arrangements by the Service Lead for responsibility for planning between 6 and 12 months following implementation.”.

Councillor Gaines introduced the report and highlighted that Local Councils had been given no choice in making the proposed changes as Government planning reforms required the new process to be adopted by 31 October 2026. After that, the Council would be legally required to determine all Schedule 1 applications by officer delegation and only Schedule 2 applications that meet certain tests would be referred to the Planning Committee. The test would be to determine if the application was a significant planning, economic, social, or environmental matter to the local area. There was also a risk to the Council if the changes were not approved, such as the potential non-determination of applications and the risk of appeals and Judicial Reviews resulting in costs being awarded against the Council.

One of the other key changes highlighted was around the removal of call-in powers from Members and objectors, resulting in a feeling like there had been a reduction in their rights over planning.

Although the legislation was non-negotiable, the local triage process for Schedule 2 applications provided some room for discretion as they would be determined by the nominated officer and Member.

As these changes were expected to result in a significant decrease in applications coming to committee, a single Planning Committee was proposed to replace the existing Eastern Area, Western Area, and District Planning Committees.

Councillor Gaines also indicated that planning officers had liaised with South Oxfordshire and Vale of White Horse District Councils to ensure that this scheme could work when the Councils merged into Ridgeway Council. She also stressed that the new scheme would be reviewed between six and 12 Months from when it was actioned in order to make improvements on the process.

 

MOTION: Proposed by Councillor Stephanie Steevenson and seconded by Councillor Martha Vickers:

“That the Council amend speaking rights for this item so that:

·       The Proposer of the Amendment is allowed 10 Minutes

·       The Seconder of the Amendment is allowed 6 Minutes

·       The Proposer of the original Motion is allowed 10 Minutes”

The Motion was put to the meeting and duly RESOLVED.

 

AMENDMENT: Proposed by Councillor Adrian Abbs and seconded by Councillor Carolyn Culver:

“That the following amendments be made to the reports:

1.    Appendix F: the Nominated Officer to be the Chief Planning Officer; remove the Executive Member with responsibility for Planning as a substitute Nominated Member.

2.    8.1.2: the Nominated Member and substitutes to be appointed by Full Council or Planning Committee, with any changes reported to the next meeting.

3.    8.1.10(c): add a right to re-flag within 14 days of any re-consultation or material amendment; nominated persons to notify the flagging member, and the parish/town council, of the outcome and reasons before determination.

4.    8.1.10: add triage triggers for (i) a parish/town council objection where the recommendation is approval, and (ii) any proposal contrary to a made Neighbourhood Plan.

5.    8.1.15: decisions and reasons published on the website within 5 working days and reported to every Planning Committee meeting.

6.    8.1.6: insert 'subject to 8.1.9(b)' so own-interest Schedule 1 applications can be referred; widen 8.1.10(d) to cases where the Council, a member or an officer 'has an interest'; add an express recusal clause (guidance para 26).

7.    8.1.7: delete (a)–(c) (keep them as Schedule 2, outside automatic triage) and remove the duplication between (c) and (e).

8.    8.1.17 / Rec 2.3: limit to changes required by statute, guidance or a court decision; consult Group Leaders; report to the next ordinary Council.

9.    Rec 2.4: review to be carried out by Scrutiny or the Constitution Review Task Group, with published data; any change to triage to return to Full Council.

10. Appendix B 4.1: Planning Committee of 13 members, with a minimum drawn from each of the former east and west areas."

Councillor Abbs spoke to the amendment, noting that it was the law but that the Council should make the best of the requirements. He also indicated that the existing situation was working well and rejected the stated purpose of legislation as Councillors were not the cause of slow determination of applications. The proposed amendments did not look to delay the implementation of the proposal, but to ensure that the Council was only doing the minimum of what was required. He then clarified a number of the points proposed to Council.

Members welcomed the proposals but highlighted that there were a number of detailed points that had been provided without sufficient notice to fully examine them in advance. Questions were also raised about what Council could amend in the report, and what was required by the legislation.

Council noted that the Constitution was regularly reviewed and so these proposed amendments could be considered after the approval of the recommendations. This would ensure the Council did not risk missing the 31 October deadline. The governance process for this review would take the amendments through the Constitution Review Task Group, the Audit and Risk Committee, potentially the Resources and Place Scrutiny Committee, and then finally full Council for determination. Some Members wanted the review of the proposals to be sooner than six months, suggesting that three months would be preferable.

On the nominated Members, it was noted that the Chairman of the Planning Committee would be the nominated Member and if they were unavailable, it would be the Vice-Chairman, and then the relevant Portfolio Holder. This was proposed in order to avoid having a single point of failure. 

Ward Members were encouraged to look more closely at all applications in their area and contact the planning officer with any resident’s input. It was also confirmed that decisions relating to the Schedule 2 determinations would be published on the website for public viewing.

Council regretted the requirements that had been handed down by Central Government but were satisfied that there was scope to review the proposal without needing to approve the amendments at this point in time.

The Amendment was put to the vote and declared NOT CARRIED.

Council returned to debate the Substantive Motion.

Members reiterated that the government legislation undermined the democratic role of local government and refuted the claims that housing delays were due to Members involvement in the process, or due to environmental and sustainability requirements. The previous system was working well and deliberation was done effectively. A potential solution to planning delays without these forced changes could be for the Government to provide local authorities the funds to recruit more planning officers to speed up the deliberation process.

The role of Members was to look at an application, policy, and the exceptional circumstances around the application to make a balanced judgment. This was the role that the legislation undermined, resulting in a situation where parish and town Councils would have more involvement in the planning process than the District Councillors.

With a single planning committee, some Members were concerned about the milage they would have to do to attend site visits across the district. The workload placed on the nominated Member was also a concern as every parish council, resident, and Member would be going to them to lobby on their applications.

Members were assured that these arrangements would be reviewed in six to nine months and the outcome would come back to them for consideration.

One potential positive resulting from these changes was that, now, Members would be free to get involved and lobby for applications in their wards without risk of fettering their discretion as the application would not be going to a committee.

Council was encouraged to make it clear to residents that this was not something the Council wanted to do, but that it was forced on them by Central Government. The Executive were also suggested to write to Secretary of State to express the displeasure of Council at the changes being forced on them.

Overall, Council agreed to approve the recommendations.

The Motion was put to the meeting and duly RESOLVED.

 

Supporting documents: