Agenda item
Notices of Motion
To receive any Motions submitted in accordance with the Council Procedure Rules contained in the Council's Constitution.
Minutes:
Adjournment of meeting: Proposed by Councillor Stephanie Steevenson and Seconded by Councillor Martha Vickers.
RESOLVED: In accordance with the Council’s Constitution, Part 3, point 19.1.2, the Council supported the motion to hold a short adjournment.
The Council reconvened and considered the under-mentioned Motion (of which Agenda Item 16(a) refers) submitted in the name of Councillor David Marsh relating to ending of the use of the chemical weedkiller glyphosate.
The Chairman informed Council that the Motion would not be debated. In accordance with Procedure Rule 12.6.1, it would be referred to the Executivefor consideration without debate as the subject matter fell within their remit.
Councillor David Marsh raised a point of order, requesting this decision be reconsidered due to a perceived lack of consistency in which Motions were referred and which ones were debated. However, the Chairman confirmed that, as this Motion fell within the remit of the Executive, it should be referred to the decision-making body responsible for those functions.
MOTION: Proposed by Councillor David Marsh and seconded by Councillor Carolyne Culver:
“Ending the use of the chemical weedkiller glyphosate
Council notes that:
The chemical weedkiller glyphosate, which has been designated a “probable carcinogen” by the World Health Organisation, is a threat to both human health and the natural world.
Glyphosate residues are found in our food, in our tap water, and in our bodies. It is devastating for wildlife, killing bees and other insects while stripping away food and shelter for birds and mammals, and polluting our rivers.
Many local authorities have banned or are phasing out the use of glyphosate based pesticides on public land. Lee Dillon, MP for Newbury, is one of 35 MPs to sign Commons Early Day Motion 607, Pesticides in Public Spaces, which commends more than 100 local authorities across the UK that have either ended or significantly reduced their use of pesticides, and calls on more councils to do so.
The MPs also express support for the Plant Protection Products (Prohibition on Public Sector Use) Bill, tabled by Sian Berry MP in May 2026, which would introduce a national phase-out of pesticide use in public spaces.
However, many councils and other public authorities still use pesticides to manage unwanted vegetation. In 2024, 354 tonnes of pesticides were sprayed by councils across our towns and cities in the UK. Residues have been found in more than half the playgrounds analysed by Pesticide Action Network UK.
The Soil Association and an increasing number of growers, conservation groups, and wildlife charities, which are supported by many thousands of our residents, are calling for a complete nationwide ban when the government reviews its glyphosate licences in December 2026.
Council therefore resolves:
1. To commit to end the use of glyphosate-based herbicides and pesticides on land owned or managed by West Berkshire Council, due to the associated risks and potential damage to human and animal health.
2. This policy to be phased over 24 months in to allow the exploration and trialling of alternatives to the use of herbicides in public spaces and an alternative method for removing weeds from the highway.
3. To alert residents of West Berkshire to the health and environmental risks associated with glyphosate (used in widely available weedkillers).
4. To promote to residents the benefits of pollinator-friendly gardens and green spaces where insects such as bees and butterflies can thrive”
Councillor Marsh introduced the motion and highlighted that Glyphosate was a threat to human health and the natural world and had been designated as a probable carcinogen by the World Health Organisation in 2015. Residues had been found in bread, tap water, and human bodies, and Members noted that exposure to the chemical was linked to reproductive defects, developmental disorders, and cancers.
Usage of the chemical had risen 1,000 per cent since 1990, despite the findings that there was no accepted safe level of exposure. More than 100 local authorities had already banned or were phasing out its usage on public land and the Newbury MP had also signed the early day motion in the House of Commons commending councils for doing this. However, it was still widely used and in 2024, 354 tonnes had been sprayed by councils.
West Berkshire Council had reduced its reliance on the chemical. The Countryside team only used small amounts, which could be eliminated. However, its use by the Highways team was more significant, and thus more difficult to eliminate. For this reason, the Motion proposed a two-year period to phase in alternatives.
The relevant Portfolio Holder, Councillor Stuart Gourley, responded to the Motion, informing Council that the Administration would respond fully after getting officer input. He also informed Members that the Council kept pesticide and herbicide usage to a minimum.
The chemical was mainly used in two areas, public highways and in parks and countryside, however, this was generally limited to areas where alternatives were not effective or proportionate. Councillor Gourley also noted that there were a number of case studies from across the country with varying degrees of success, and so he welcomed the proposal.
The Council then considered the under-mentioned Motion (of which Agenda Item 16(b) refers) submitted in the name of Councillor Nick Carter relating to developments proposed in the Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council Local Plan consultation which adjoin West Berkshire, and a proposed West Berkshire Council response.
The Chairman informed Council that should the Motion be proposed and seconded, then it would be debated in order to facilitate the discharge of business in accordance with Procedure Rule 12.6.3.
MOTION: Proposed by Councillor Nick Carter and seconded by Councillor Denise Gaines:
That the Council:
“Response to Basingstoke and Deane Local Plan
This Council notes that:
- Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council’s Regulation 18 Local Plan consultation includes a proposed allocation of approximately 350 dwellings at Land at West End Farm, Mortimer West End.
- This site would function in practice as an extension of Stratfield Mortimer, a settlement within West Berkshire, and would rely substantially on West Berkshire infrastructure and services, including healthcare, education, transport, utilities and environmental assets.
- West Berkshire Council, ward members, parish councils and residents have submitted detailed representations raising concerns regarding cross boundary infrastructure capacity, deliverability, environmental constraints, and consistency with Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council’s stated spatial strategy.
- The proposed level of development at Mortimer West End would represent a significant population increase relative to the size and infrastructure capacity of Stratfield Mortimer.
- There is currently no clear, funded and agreed mechanism demonstrating how cross-boundary infrastructure impacts would be mitigated or how West Berkshire services would be protected from additional pressure.
- Questions have been raised regarding the consistent application of Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council’s own site selection methodology, settlement hierarchy principles and strategic constraints — including the treatment of AWE emergency-planning constraints and cross-boundary infrastructure reliance — when compared with other candidate sites within the borough.
The Council appreciates the positive engagement that has taken place with Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council to date.
Notwithstanding that, this Council believes that:
· Development immediately adjacent to the West Berkshire boundary must be infrastructure-led and supported by robust, proportionate and transparent evidence.
· West Berkshire residents should not experience degradation of healthcare access, school capacity, transport safety, wastewater performance or environmental quality as a consequence of an adjacent Council’s Local Plan.
· Cross-boundary sites must be subject to the same transparent and consistent application of settlement hierarchy principles, infrastructure tests and environmental constraints as sites located within Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council’s own defined service centres.
This Council therefore resolves to:
1. Formally write to Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council requesting:
· Clear evidence of how cross-boundary infrastructure impacts will be assessed, funded and delivered prior to allocation at Regulation 19.
· Publication of any site-specific transport, healthcare, wastewater and environmental capacity assessments relevant to West Berkshire residents.
· Clarification of how the Council’s site selection methodology and spatial strategy criteria have been applied consistently across all candidate sites, including the treatment of AWE emergency-planning constraints, settlement hierarchy principles and cross-boundary infrastructure reliance.
2. Seek formal engagement with Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council and relevant infrastructure providers to ensure that West Berkshire’s interests are fully represented in ongoing plan preparation.
3. Request that no future allocation adjoining West Berkshire by Basingstoke and Deane Borough Council should proceed unless and until proportionate, deliverable and secured mitigation is evidenced for impacts falling within West Berkshire.
4. Continue to support residents and parish councils in ensuring that cross boundary impacts are properly considered through the Local Plan process.”
Councillor Carter introduced the motion and highlighted that it was a response to development on West End Farm which was located just over the border from West Berkshire, inside Basingstoke and Deane. This development would essentially form an extension of Mortimer West End. As it was located some distance from the railway station, and had no continuous active travel routes, the lack of clarity about the necessary infrastructure that would be needed for the additional 350 homes was raised as a concern. In addition, this housing figure was noted as being one fifth of the current residential population.
As he believed that it would not function as a self-contained settlement, Councillor Carter stressed the importance of the infrastructure delivery for the site. This infrastructure was requested to be costed and proven to be sustainable. In addition, the adopted Stratfield Mortimer Neighbourhood Plan had not accounted for this site as it was outside the Plan area.
Council debated the motion but agreed to the importance of working with Basingstoke and Deane’s Members and Officers constructively in order to solve any infrastructure problems. However, some Members were sceptical of the Motion as they noted that these conversations had already been ongoing for a long period of time, and that the period for consultation responses (called the Regulation 18 stage) was over. In response however, it was generally agreed that the Motion would be an effective way of formalising the Council’s position on the proposed development and demonstrating to residents that they were working to address their concerns.
Overall, as Council was satisfied with the Motion as proposed, they agreed to approve the recommendation.
The Motion was put to the vote and declared CARRIED.
Supporting documents: