Agenda item
Scheme for Financing Schools 2026/27 (Edith Cheng)
Minutes:
Edith Cheng introduced the report (Agenda Item 6), which sought approval to adopt the updated Scheme for Financing Schools following consultation with maintained schools. It was noted that the scheme had been reviewed following publication of updated Department for Education (DfE) guidance and that consultation had taken place with maintained schools between 16 and 26 June 2026. Eleven responses had been received, with one school supporting the proposals and ten schools raising concerns regarding aspects of the amendments. Following consideration of the responses, the Local Authority (LA) recommended that the proposed amendments remain unchanged.
Brett Melvill-Smith referred to concerns raised during the consultation regarding Period Three (P3) monitoring. He commented that key information, including budgets and pay awards, was often unavailable at that stage of the financial year and queried whether consideration had been given to returning to the previous Period 6 and Period 9 reporting arrangements. Edith Cheng advised that earlier monitoring would provide a better indication of a school's financial position and any emerging concerns. Brett Melvill-Smith questioned the value of requiring schools to complete detailed reports when forecasts were subject to significant uncertainty.
Ashley Milum acknowledged that P3 reporting would inevitably contain a degree of uncertainty. However, he explained that the intention was to facilitate earlier discussions with schools and enable appropriate support and challenge where concerns were identified. He added that information submitted at P3 would be considered in the context of the known uncertainties present at that stage of the financial year.
Rebecca Hartley expressed concern that some schools had chosen not to respond to the consultation because they felt nothing would change. She suggested that if comments were not taken into account this could discourage engagement in future consultations. Rebecca Hartley also questioned whether sufficient capacity existed within the finance team to manage the additional monitoring requirements and provide appropriate support to schools experiencing financial difficulty, or whether there were plans to increase capacity within the team.
Ashley Milum acknowledged these concerns and emphasised the importance of considering the consultation feedback carefully. He explained that the proposed changes were intended to align local arrangements more closely with DfE expectations and would support benchmarking through Integrated Curriculum and Financial Planning, and other DfE support mechanisms. He noted that a significantly higher proportion of maintained schools in West Berkshire were operating in deficit when compared to national figures and therefore there was a need to consider the issue carefully and take appropriate action. He added that due regard should be given to the consultation responses and that members would need to consider whether any amendments to the recommendations were required.
In response to Rebecca Hartley’s concerns regarding capacity, Ashley Milum advised that discussions were already taking place as part of budget planning for the next financial year and consideration was being given to how schools in, or approaching, deficit could be supported. He explained that the scheme would provide a framework through which support and challenge could be delivered and acknowledged that this had previously been lacking. Ashley Milum added that any arrangements would need to be implemented in a sensible and pragmatic manner, particularly for schools already operating in deficit and confirmed that further engagement with schools and governing boards was planned from September 2026.
Rebecca Hartley queried whether implementation should be delayed until additional capacity was in place. Ashley Milum advised that this was a matter for the Forum to consider and noted that members could support the proposals, request amendments, or seek transitional arrangements.
Brett Melvill-Smith also referred to concerns raised during the consultation regarding the proposal to reduce deficit recovery plans from five years to three years. He commented that some schools remained vulnerable to fluctuations in pupil numbers and could find returning to a balanced position within three years particularly challenging.
Ashley Milum acknowledged the concerns raised and explained that the proposed three-year recovery period aligned with DfE expectations. He reiterated that a higher proportion of maintained schools in West Berkshire were operating in deficit compared to the national position and suggested that the Forum needed to consider how it wished to respond to this. Ashley Milum advised that conversations would be required with individual schools, particularly those already operating in deficit, regarding how their position would continue to be managed. He added that aligning with DfE expectations would be helpful and could provide greater impetus for schools to progress towards a more sustainable financial position. He further noted that additional support and resources would enable a more comprehensive approach to supporting and challenging schools and would help the Forum address this issue going forward.
Brett Melvill-Smith suggested that additional analysis might be required to understand the relationship between school deficits and surplus places and queried whether comparisons with national figures took account of factors such as school closures elsewhere. Ashley Milum acknowledged that this was a fair consideration and advised that further work could be undertaken to explore the issue. It was noted that there was not always a direct correlation between deficit budgets and surplus school places.
Keith Harvey commented that he would be more comfortable delaying implementation until the necessary staffing capacity was in place, although he recognised the need to move towards DfE expectations and suggested that this could provide schools with additional notice of the proposed changes.
David Ramsden commented that, given the current financial context, aligning with DfE expectations was important. Whilst recognising the challenges faced by schools, he suggested that a five-year recovery period could give the impression that insufficient action was being taken to address deficits and expressed support for the LA’s proposed approach.
The Chair thanked members for their contributions and noted the constructive discussion that had taken place. The recommendations were proposed and seconded and at the vote with maintained school members, the motion was carried.
RESOLVED that the Schools’ Forum approved the proposed amendments and agreed to adopt and publish the updated Scheme for Financing Schools.
Supporting documents:
-
6. Scheme for Financing Schools - Consultation Responses Report, item 5.
PDF 206 KB -
6. Appendix A - SFS Consultation Responses, item 5.
PDF 317 KB