To report any issues with the information below please email executivecycle@westberks.gov.uk.

Agenda and draft minutes

Venue: Council Chamber Council Offices Market Street Newbury

Contact: Stephen Chard (Democratic Services Manager) 

Media

Items
No. Item

1.

Election of Chairman

Minutes:

As the Chairman and Vice-Chairman had issued their apologies for the meeting due to a declaration of interest, the meeting determined to elect a Chairman for the meeting.

MOTION: Proposed by Councillor Ross Mackinnon and seconded by Councillor Dominic Boeck:

“That Councillor Clive Hooker be elected as Chairman for this meeting.”

The Motion was put to the meeting and duly RESOLVED.

As the Personnel and Standards Committee could not deal with this complaint due to the nature of Members’ interests, resulting in it being inquorate, Council resolved to adopt the procedure outlined in the Constitution for dealing with standards complaints.

MOTION: Proposed by Councillor Clive Hooker and seconded by Councillor Ross Mackinnon:

“That the meeting adopts the complaints procedure outlined in Part 13, Appendix A, paragraphs 10.2 through until paragraph 12 of the Constitution.”

The Motion was put to the meeting and duly RESOLVED.

2.

Declarations of Interest pdf icon PDF 305 KB

To remind Members of the need to record the existence and nature of any personal, disclosable pecuniary or other registrable interests in items on the agenda, in accordance with the Members’ Code of Conduct.

Minutes:

All Members of the Liberal Democrat Group declared a non-registerable interest in Agenda Item 4 as one of the parties to the Standards Complaint was a doner to their political party and whom a number knew in a personal capacity. Therefore, in order to avoid the perception of bias, they determined to not participate in the meeting in any way.

Councillor Joanne Stewart declared a personal interest in Agenda Item 4 as one of the parties referenced in the report is known to her in a personal capacity. However, as this was a personal interest not prejudicial, she determined to remain in the meeting and participate in the discussion and deliberation.

Councillor Richard Somner declared an interest in Agenda Item 4 as he had communicated with the Subject Member in 2004 regarding a neighbourhood development plan. However, as this was not prejudicial, he determined to remain in the meeting and participate in the discussion and deliberation.

Councillor Adrian Abbs declared an interest in Agenda Item 4 as he was previously a member of the Liberal Democrats. However, as he had no recollection of meeting or talking to the Subject Member, he did not believe it to be prejudicial and so determined to remain in the meeting and participate in the discussion and deliberation.

The Chairman declared an interest in Agenda Item 4 as he believed he might have historically communicated with the Subject Member. However, as he had no recollection of any discussions, he did not believe it to be prejudicial and so determined to remain in the meeting and participate in the discussion and deliberation.

3.

Exclusion of Press and Public pdf icon PDF 309 KB

RECOMMENDATION:

 

That members of the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of the following items as it is likely that there would be disclosure of exempt information of the description contained in the paragraphs of Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972 specified in brackets in the heading of each item. Section 10 of Part 10 of the Constitution outlines the exclusion of the press and public to meetings.

 

 

Minutes:

Council heard representations from the Legal Advisor, Subject Member, and Complainant on whether to exclude the press and public from the discussion of Agenda Item 4. Although there was a strong presumption that the meeting should be held in public, Members had to balance this against the rights of third-party individuals referenced in the report who did not have an opportunity to consider the report or make representations.

MOTION: Proposed by Councillor Clive Hooker and seconded by Councillor Ross Mackinnon:

“That members of the press and public be excluded from the meeting for the under-mentioned item of business on the grounds that it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as contained in Paragraph 1 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972, as amended by the Local Government (Access to Information)(Variation) Order 2006. Section 10, Part 10 of the Constitution also refers.”

The Motion was not resolved when it was put to the vote.

After consideration of the relevant legislation, Council agreed to not exclude the press and public from the remainder of the meeting. However, the appendixes to the report would remain restricted in order to preserve the rights of the referenced third-party individuals.

4.

Standards Complaint - Outcome of Full Investigation pdf icon PDF 286 KB

Additional documents:

Minutes:

Council considered a report (Agenda Item 4) concerning a complaint regarding an alleged breach of the Cold Ash Parish Council Code of Conduct. The complaint was submitted by a member of the public, Mr Gavin Bailey (Complainant), on 22 September 2025 against the then Councillor Bernard Clark (Subject Member).

Members were required to determine whether a breach of the Code had occurred after considering the Independent Investigator’s report and hearing from both the Complainant and Subject Member. Should the Committee determine that there had been a breach, they would need to determine an appropriate sanction.

 

Presentation from the Independent Investigator

The Independent Investigator, Michael Graham, presented his report. The key points highlighted were:

  • The events mentioned in the report occurred several years ago and the heart of the matter revolved around the rights of the Complainant to not be subject to abuse or bullying and those of the Subject Member to be able to speak freely on matters of public importance.
  • Reference to rights enshrined by Article 10 of the European Convention of Human Rights (ECHR) were raised by the Subject Member.
  • The sequence of events were as follows: 1) The Complainant emailed the Cold Ash Parish Council Clerk to express concerns about how the Council dealt with sensitive planning matters, about the rudeness of Members, the accuracy of minutes, and the appearance of bias and conflicts of interest. 2) The Parish response was personalised as the Subject Member got involved with the complaint. 3) The Complainant issued a Freedom of Information (FoI) request two years after this incident and discovered the messages that were presented in the agenda pack. 4) The Complainant submitted a Code of Conduct complaint against the Subject Member to the Monitoring Officer of West Berkshire Council.
  • The Subject Member could have reflected on the comments he made several years previously and apologised to the Complainant. However, he did not do so and cited his Article 10 rights under the ECHR.
  • The totality of his comments made at the Council meeting were not know but were likely sufficiently embarrassing as they were not recorded in the minutes.
  • The Subject Member also made derogatory comments against the Complainant in response to the Code of Conduct complaint.
  • Overall, the report concluded that some, but not all, of the comments made by the Subject Member amounted to a breach of the Code of Conduct under paragraphs 1.1 (treating councillors and members of the public with respect) and 5.1 (about not bringing the authority into disrepute). 
  • Case law for Article 10 of the ECHR indicated that politicians should have a thick skin when it came to receiving comments about potential wrongdoing or their competence. However, Article 10 rights were qualified and did not afford protection to individuals who abused politicians or members of the public.
  • For this reason, a balanced judgment needed to be made about the benefits of free speech against the rights of individuals not to be abused and to ensure that the system maintained public trust –  ...  view the full minutes text for item 4.