Agenda and draft minutes
Venue: Council Chamber Council Offices Market Street Newbury
Contact: Gordon Oliver (Principal Democratic Services Officer) Email: Gordon.Oliver1@westberks.gov.uk
Media
| No. | Item |
|---|---|
|
To approve as a correct record the Minutes of the meeting of this Committee held on 23 June 2026 and the Minutes of the two extraordinary meetings held on 28 July 2026. Additional documents:
Minutes: The Minutes of the meeting held on 23 June 2026 were approved as a true and correct record and signed by the Chairman. The Minutes of the first extraordinary meeting held on 28 July 2026 were approved as a true and correct record and signed by the Chairman. The Minutes of the second extraordinary meeting held on 28 July 2026 were approved as a true and correct record and signed by the Chairman. |
|
|
Purpose: To be informed about the actions taken from past meetings. Minutes: The Committee considered the Action Log (Agenda Item 3). It was noted that action 26-20 was still in progress and had not been completed as indicated in the Action Log. Satisfied with the information presented, the Committee agreed that the updates could be noted. |
|
|
Declarations of Interest To remind Members of the need to record the existence and nature of any personal, disclosable pecuniary or other registrable interests in items on the agenda, in accordance with the Members’ Code of Conduct. Minutes: There were no declarations of interest received. |
|
|
Purpose: To consider the work programme for the next 12 months. Minutes: Officers requested that the Strategic Risk Register Update be slipped from the November meeting to the January meeting to allow it to be presented alongside the Internal Audit update. The Committee agreed to this amendment.
|
|
|
Planning Constitution Amendments - National Scheme of Delegations This report asks Council to approve amendments to the Council’s Constitution to: a) Implement the National Scheme of Delegation for planning functions, as introduced under the Planning and Infrastructure Act 2025 and given effect by the Town and Country Planning (Discharge of Local Planning Authority Functions) (England) Regulations 2026. b) Establish a single Planning Committee to replace District Planning Committee, Eastern Area Planning Committee and Western Area Planning Committee. c) Implement other minor amendments to the Constitution relating to Planning.
Additional documents:
Minutes: Councillor Denise Gaines (Executive Portfolio Holder – Planning and Housing) and Bob Dray (Interim Service Lead – Planning) presented the proposed Planning Constitution Amendments (Agenda Item 6). The following points were raised in the debate: · It was confirmed that there had been no feedback from the Constitution Review Task Group regarding the proposed amendments. · There was a question about whether officers and Members would have sufficient guidance and training to minimise the risk of legal challenges around the interpretation and application of the gateway tests. Officers explained that one of the tests for an application to be referred to committee was around the significance of the application. This was a matter of planning judgement, which was why an experienced planning officer would be involved. Statutory guidance provided examples of how to interpret the tests. There would be regular meetings between the nominated Member and officer, with a legal advisor present until all parties were familiar with the process. A proforma was being developed, which would contain relevant questions/prompts and would also act as a record of the decision as to why each application was referred to committee or not. · Officers were asked how the anticipated efficiencies of going from three planning committees to one would be measured. It was confirmed that the main measure would be the number of applications going to committee, which would be extracted from back office systems, with a Power BI dashboard providing live data. · It was noted that under current arrangements, District Planning Committee only met when applications were referred up from one of the Area Planning Committees. Also, there was a significant imbalance in the number of applications being considered by the two Area Planning Committees. Moving to a single committee should reduce the number of meetings that had to be cancelled due to a lack of applications. · Members asked about what weight would be given to letters from residents in relation to particular planning applications. It was explained that the number of letters received was not a material planning consideration - what mattered was the content of those letters. · It was noted that ‘Member flagging’ would replace the current call-in system. However, this would only be used to ‘flag’ the application to the nominated Member and officer for consideration. An online form was being developed for this purpose, with supporting guidance to explain the legal tests. · Clarification was sought as to whether Ward Members would be expected to submit letters of support/objection under the new system. It was confirmed that they would be able to make representations in the same way as anyone else. · Officers were asked what measures would be put in place to ensure that triage and gateway test processes for Schedule 2 applications were transparent and robust. It was explained that there was a requirement for every decision of the nominated Member and officer to be recorded – these would be included in the officer’s report. Back office systems were due to be updated to pull this information to the ... view the full minutes text for item 24. |
|
|
Internal Audit Update Report: Q1 2026/27 Purpose: To update the Committee on the status of Internal Audit work as at the end of Quarter One 2026/27. Additional documents:
Minutes: Julie Gillhelspie (Audit Manager) presented the Internal Audit Update Report: Q1 2026/27 (Agenda Item 7). The following points were raised in the debate: · April Peberdy (Service Director - Community Services) was invited to provide an update in relation to recommendations made following a previous audit of the West Berkshire Lottery. She confirmed that an officer had now been recruited whose duties would include management of the lottery contract. Their priority upon starting would be to address the points raised within the audit report in relation to the lottery. · Members expressed concern that the audit only provided limited assurance in relation to compliance with Gambling Commission requirements. It was explained that this was a potential risk of not having a contract in place. The contractor was experienced and provided similar services to other local authorities, so the risk was considered low, but if it did occur, then the Council would incur reputational damage. RESOLVED to note the report. |
|
|
Strategic Risk Register: Q1 2026/27 To highlight the corporate risks that need to be considered by the Audit and Risk Committee and to outline the actions taken to mitigate those risks. Minutes: Martyn Sargeant (Service Director – Strategy and Governance) presented the Strategic Risk Register for Quarter 1 2026/27 (Agenda Item 8). The following points were raised in the debate: · Officers were asked why details of the corporate risks were restricted to the Part II appendix. It was felt that most people could guess what they were, and it was suggested that the opportunity was being missed to provide reassurance to residents that the Council recognised the risks and had suitable mitigations in place. · It was noted that the Audit Manager had taken on responsibility for the Strategic Risk Register and would be responsible for preparing the Quarter 2 update. Officers indicated that they would take on board Members comments about the value of the public report. · Officers referenced another council which published its risk register in full. Concerns were expressed that this approach meant putting the local authority’s cyber risks and mitigations into the public domain. Officers indicated that for Quarter 2, more detail may be included in the Part I report. However, there needed to be a balance between transparency and not exposing the Council to unnecessary risk by publishing too much information. · Members did not see any specifics in the Part II report that could potentially expose the Council to additional risk if the information was put in the public domain. It was suggested that the Council should adopt a ‘transparency as a default’ approach, with risks only discussed in private where there was a clear case for doing so. Officers confirmed that ‘transparency as a default’ was the legal position and material was published on the basis of an assessment of risk. However, officers undertook to review reporting to see what could be put into the public domain. · Reference was made to the Grazeley Solar Farm report that had been discussed at Resources and Place Scrutiny Committee. Members felt that some of the material discussed in Part II appendix could have been included in the public meeting - this would have helped residents to satisfy themselves that the Council’s proposal was sound. Action: Officers to consider whether additional information could be included within the Part I element of the Strategic Risk Register report in future. RESOLVED to note the report. |
|
|
Exclusion of Press and Public RECOMMENDATION: That members of the press and public be excluded from the meeting during consideration of the following items as it is likely that there would be disclosure of exempt information of the description contained in the paragraphs of Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972 specified in brackets in the heading of each item. Section 10 of Part 10 of the Constitution refers.
Minutes: RESOLVED: That members of the press and public be excluded from the meeting for the under-mentioned item of business on the grounds that it involves the likely disclosure of exempt information as contained in Paragraphs 3, 5 and 6 of Part 1 of Schedule 12A of the Local Government Act 1972, as amended by the Local Government (Access to Information)(Variation) Order 2006. Section 10, Part 10 of the Constitution also refers. |
|
|
Strategic Risk Register - Q1 2026-27 (Paragraph 3 – information relating to financial/business affairs of particular person) (Paragraph 5 – information relating to legal privilege) (Paragraph 5 – information relating to proposed action to be taken by the Local Authority) Minutes: (Paragraph 3 – information relating to financial/business affairs of a particular person) (Paragraph 5 – information relating to legal privilege) (Paragraph 5 – information relating to proposed action to be taken by the Local Authority) The Committee considered an exempt report (Agenda Item 10) concerning Strategic Risk Register - Q1 2026-27. RESOLVED to note the report. |
PDF 332 KB