Agenda and minutes
Venue: Council Chamber Council Offices Market Street Newbury. View directions
Contact: Stephen Chard (Democratic Services Manager)
Media
| No. | Item |
|---|---|
|
To approve as a correct record the Minutes of the meeting of the Committee held on 17 March 2026, 12 May 2026 (to follow) and 14 May 2026. Additional documents:
Minutes: The Minutes of the meeting held on 17 March 2026 were approved as a true and correct record and signed by the Chairman. The Minutes of the meeting held on 12 May 2026 were approved as a true and correct record and signed by the Chairman, subject to the following amendment: Item 4 – Environment Strategy Annual Report (page 7, bullet point 4) – the Committee agreed that the need to ensure sufficient watering of newly planted trees would be recommended to the Executive. This was particularly important considering the heatwave conditions being experienced. This recommendation would be added to the actions/recommendations log. The Minutes of the meeting held on 14 May 2026 were approved as a true and correct record and signed by the Chairman. |
|
|
Actions from previous Minutes To receive an update on recommendations and actions following previous Committee meetings. Additional documents:
Minutes: Members reviewed the actions from the previous meetings. The following point was noted: · 270 (Grazeley Solar Farm) – the date for the Committee to consider the Business Case for this project would need to be rearranged as the 15 September 2026 was reserved for the Thames Water/Environment Agency scrutiny. The resolution of Committee at its meeting on 12 May 2026, that the decision made in relation to Lower Way in Thatcham would be reconsidered at ID, would be added to the actions/recommendations log. Councillor Carolyne Culver highlighted the need for the action logs of each Scrutiny Committee to monitor progress made with scrutiny recommendations that had been agreed by the Executive. |
|
|
Declarations of Interest To remind Members of the need to record the existence and nature of any personal, disclosable pecuniary or other registrable interests in items on the agenda, in accordance with the Members’ Code of Conduct. Minutes: No declarations of interest were received. |
|
|
To consider any petitions requiring an Officer response. Minutes: No petitions were received at the meeting. |
|
|
Items called-in following the meeting of the Executive on 11 June 2026 To consider the items called-in by the requisite number of Members following the meeting of the Executive on 11 June 2026. |
|
|
Called-in report - New Procurement Strategy and "Think Local" Social Value Strategy To consider the call-in request to review the Executive decision to adopt the Procurement Strategy and the “Think Local” Social Value Strategy. Additional documents:
Minutes: The Committee considered the report (Agenda Item 6a) which outlined the call-in request for the Committee to review the Executive decision of 11 June 2026 to adopt the Procurement Strategy and the “Think Local” Social Value Strategy. Councillor Vic Poole, the Portfolio Holder for Strategy and Governance, and Commercialisation, made the following points in support of the Executive’s decision: · The new Procurement Strategy had been developed in response to the Public Procurement Act 2023, which had brought in substantial legislative changes. Because of the scale of the changes, the Council had started from scratch in preparing the Strategy. · The Strategy was an overarching document touching many areas of the Council’s business. Councillor Poole advised that further metrics and delivery detail would follow as implementation progressed. The following points were made by Councillor Ross Mackinnon, one of the call-in Members: · He stated that the previous Social Value Policy had been adopted when he was Portfolio Holder and expressed concern that comments made at Executive had suggested that this earlier Policy had not been taken into account or given any weight in forming the new Strategy. · The Committee needed to be satisfied that the previous Policy had been taken into account, that it had been complied with and that the new Strategy properly explained how it built on or replaced the earlier position. · It was important to demonstrate that procurement decisions had been and would be made in accordance with policy. Without this there was a risk to the Council of legal challenge. · It was important, for monitoring purposes, to be able to identify the level of local spend, how local spend was defined, the extent of local suppliers and the targets being set. This would enable scrutiny to take place. · Call-in Members requested that the new Strategy be strengthened prior to final adoption with assurance provided on the points that had been raised. Councillor Poole and Richard Howroyd (Service Lead – Procurement and Commissioning) made the following points in response to those comments: · Councillor Poole explained that information was held in relation to targets and data. It had been included within Appendix 1 of the Procurement Strategy. Mr Howroyd added that Appendix 1 contained a summary of local spend, regional spend and spend by category/service area. · Mr Howroyd had introduced a detailed spend analysis system since joining the Council which allowed expenditure to be analysed by individual supplier, category and other criteria. Further information on this could be provided to the Committee. · Councillor Poole went on to state that over the previous three years the Council’s spend with small to medium sized enterprises (SMEs) had been around 50%, which compared favourably to the local government average of 34%. Spend with local SMEs was in the region of 14% and there was a target to increase that to 20%. · In response to the point on legal challenge, Councillor Poole pointed out that it was necessary to regularly adapt to legislative change, and the new Strategy was produced on that basis. Training and ... view the full minutes text for item 5a |
|
|
Called-in report - Planning Enforcement Plan 2026 To consider the call-in request to review the Executive decision to adopt the West Berkshire Council Planning Enforcement Plan 2026. Additional documents:
Minutes: The Committee considered the report (Agenda Item 6b) which outlined the call-in request for the Committee to review the Executive decision of 11 June 2026 to adopt the Planning Enforcement Plan 2026. Councillor Denise Gaines, Portfolio Holder for Planning and Housing, made the following points in support of the Executive’s decision: · An enforcement plan was not a statutory requirement, but it was a useful tool to guide enforcement investigations and ensure that actions taken were both consistent and transparent. · The plan had been refreshed and modified in order to update the priority classifications so that officer effort could be focused on the most significant breaches in a timelier way. Cases were prioritised into four categories:
Councillor Gaines stated that all cases would receive some level of investigation via the initial assessment. There would not be a case of permanent inaction as had been suggested in the reasons for call-in. The following points were made by the call-in Members: · It was fully accepted that planning enforcement cases needed prioritisation when considering the enforcement workload and budget constraints. However, it was important to be transparent with residents on the timeframe for a case to be reviewed, particularly if it was assessed as being Category 4. An appropriate level of communication needed to take place with residents, including if the decision was made to not pursue a case. · There was concern that it was not specified whether Category 4 cases would receive an initial assessment and that some could be assessed as not being expedient to investigate. The desktop analysis might not be sufficiently thorough, particularly if mapping tools were not kept up to date. · This lower level response could result in residents not coming forward to report planning breaches and lead to further breaches. · The point was made that planning enforcement formed a major part of a Councillor’s casework. · It was not felt appropriate to have brought this item to an extraordinary Executive. Councillor Gaines made the following points in response to those comments: · She reiterated that all reported matters would receive an initial assessment. This consideration provided a level of investigation and cases would be categorised from there. Councillor Gaines did not expect many cases to be Category ... view the full minutes text for item 5b |
|
|
Called-in report - Assets Optimisation Plan To consider the call-in request to review the Executive decision to approve the Assets Optimisation Plan as the Council’s framework for the review, optimisation and disposal of its asset portfolio. Additional documents:
Minutes: The Committee considered the report (Agenda Item 6c) which outlined the call-in request for the Committee to review the Executive decision of 11 June 2026 to approve the Asset Optimisation Plan. Councillor Tom McCann, Portfolio Holder for Public Safety and Capital Projects, made the following points in support of the Executive’s decision: · He explained that the Asset Optimisation Plan formed part of a longer-term process that was already underway within the Council to maximise the use of its assets, reduce costs, increase income and secure best value. · The production of this Plan was in line with the requirements for Exceptional Financial Support (EFS). · This was a ‘business as usual’ area of activity. The following points were made by the call-in Members: · There was concern that this document was not sufficiently transparent. Greater clarification was needed of the Council’s assets, in particular those which had a local or community significance. A full schedule should be published, providing an explanation of the intention for each asset. If this information could not be published in full, then the reasons why should be explained. The Council should be open on their plans for its assets so that there was public awareness. · The Committee needed assurance that decisions on significant assets would be taken through the appropriate decision-making process following a period of consultation. · Confirmation on these steps would help to strengthen the plan. · The membership of the Assets Board and the content of its Terms of Reference were queried. Sarah Clarke, Executive Director for Resources, made the following points in response to those comments: · All Council assets were within the scope of the Asset Optimisation Plan. The Plan provided a strategic framework for systematically reviewing and categorising the assets in order to identify, for example, those which were being fully utilised and those with potential for improved use. If an asset was identified as potentially surplus then consideration would be given to whether it could be reused or repurposed, or disposed of, but only if appropriate. · The Plan did not alter the existing formal decision-making arrangements. Any actual disposal or optimisation decision requiring Executive approval would still need to go through the same constitutional and legal processes as before. · Mrs Clarke explained that she chaired the Assets Board. Its Terms of Reference were included as part of the Executive papers of December 2025. The Board was largely formulated by officers who held relevant responsibilities across the Council, with Member representation from Councillor Heather Codling. Its role was to provide cross-Council oversight and ensure a strategic view of assets. · Particular categories of assets were afforded protection, such as community and heritage assets, and would not be disposed of. Government guidance connected to EFS had also made clear that such assets should be protected. A number of points were then discussed in the debate and made in response to further questions. Councillor Antony Amartharaj noted the concerns raised in the call-in request, particularly in the current financial climate. However, these concerns ... view the full minutes text for item 5c |
|
|
2025/26 Financial Performance: Provisional Outturn To provide a provisional report on the financial performance of the Council’s Revenue and Capital year-end for the 2025/26 financial year. Additional documents:
Minutes: The Committee considered the Financial Performance Provisional Outturn Report for 2025/26 (Agenda Item 7). Councillor Iain Cottingham (Portfolio Holder for Finance and Resources) explained that the report covered both the revenue and capital outturn positions for 2025/26 and stressed that the figures remained provisional pending approval by the Council’s external auditors. The provisional revenue outturn showed an overspend of £5.5m which equated to a 3% adverse variance. This position was primarily driven by social care demand pressures. For Adult Social Care, the Committee was advised that there was an overspend of £3m. Councillor Cottingham advised that a major element of this related to the original budget assumption that the Council would dispose of its own care homes during the year. As that had not happened, this gave rise to a £2.1m adverse variance within the service. There was also an overspend of approximately £1 million on short-term and long-term services. For Children’s Social Care, the overspend was £3.6m, of which £3.3m related to high cost placements. A further pressure of £1m had arisen in relation to the cost of childcare lawyers. Councillor Cottingham also reported that £9.1m of the £10.7m savings programme had been achieved, representing delivery of 85% against the savings target. Turning to the capital programme, Councillor Cottingham stated that capital expenditure for the year totalled £44.5m against a planned programme of £60.9m. He advised that this reflected rephasing of expenditure rather than wholesale cancellation of projects, with some schemes slipping into future years and some expenditure also being brought forward from previous years. Councillor Cottingham commented that the Council historically achieved around a 70–75% spend rate against the capital programme per annum and efforts to improve the level of delivery were being pursued. Councillor Cottingham then highlighted a reduction in the Council’s expected Exceptional Financial Support (EFS) requirement. He stated that this would be in region of £16m to £17m rather than the £20m previously projected. Questions followed from the Committee. The following points were noted in response: · If an asset was sold, it would come off the Council’s balance sheet and generate a capital receipt which could then be used for future investment including transformation activity. · Councillor Cottingham agreed that further detail could be provided to help clarify the changes between the provisional outturn position before mitigations (£9.4m overspend) and the position post mitigations (£5.5m). However, he explained that a major factor had been a thorough review of legacy accruals on the balance sheet, particularly in social care. · It was explained that the Minimum Revenue Provision (MRP) adjustment (£5.1m) was a planned annual adjustment made in accordance with the Council’s MRP policy. This resulted in a deduction from the General Fund and a transfer into capital reserves. This would also impact on the EFS requirement. · Councillor Cottingham agreed to provide further detail on the £4.3m of transformation expenditure funded through the flexible use of capital receipts, including the amount spent on each project. · It was confirmed that Community Infrastructure Levy (CIL) funding of £1.1m ... view the full minutes text for item 6. |
|
|
2025/26 Performance Report Q4 To provide assurance that the priority areas in the Council Strategy 2023-2027 are being managed effectively as at the end of the 2025/26 year and, where performance has fallen below the expected level, present information on the remedial action taken and the impact of that action. Additional documents:
Minutes: The Committee considered the Quarter 4 Performance Report for 2025/26 (Agenda Item 8). Councillor Vic Poole (Portfolio Holder for Strategy and Governance, and Commercialisation) introduced the report, which would also be reviewed by the Executive on 2 July 2026. Prior to opening the item up for questions, Councillor Poole explained that while she would provide an answer to as many questions as possible, it might prove necessary to provide answers in relation to other portfolios post the meeting. Councillor Carolyne Culver noted that the target for the measure ‘go live with Grazeley Solar Farm’ showed as December 2025. She asked when this would be updated. Councillor Poole explained that the report retained the original target date. Any subsequent changes were outlined within the report commentary. Councillor Antony Amirtharaj felt that greater clarity was needed in the report to explain why, in some cases, the year-end RAG rating was reported as ‘Green’, but the area of work appeared to still be in progress. Councillor Poole explained that an item would only be marked as completed when it was delivered. Until then, it would be reported as RAG. Some measures would continue to be tracked over a rolling period and would therefore remain live rather than becoming a completed project. Councillor Ross Mackinnon noted that a number of ‘Red’ indicators were being reported, making specific reference to indicators within the Portfolio of Children and Family Services. He queried whether an action plan was in place in order to make improvements for ‘Red’ indicators and who was responsible for these. Councillor Poole confirmed that individual officers were responsible for the various KPIs. She pointed out that stretched targets were in place as the Council strove to reach a higher standard than that required nationally or by comparator local authorities. While Councillor Mackinnon commended this ambition, he stated that performance in these areas still needed to be taken into account and scrutinised. Councillor Poole noted that Councillor Mackinnon had submitted a question to the Leader of the Council for the Executive meeting on 2 July 2026 in relation to the mechanism for improving performance in areas rated as ‘Red’. It was therefore agreed that a fuller response would be provided at that meeting. Councillor Culver queried progress in meeting the indicator for pothole repairs. She noted that Members had previously been told that West Berkshire had a green national rating for pothole repairs, however performance was rated as ‘Red’ in the report. She queried why this was the case when the national picture suggested that the authority was performing well in this area. Councillor Poole understood that the ‘Red’ status in the report was linked to a period during which adverse weather conditions had prevented repairs from being made within the required timeframe. The status of this measure was about delivery of particular repairs and was regardless of the positive external assessment of the standard of the Council’s total road network. Sarah Clarke added that her understanding was the ... view the full minutes text for item 7. |
|
|
Task and Finish Group Guidance To consider the guidance document for scrutiny task and finish groups. Minutes: The Committee considered the draft guidance document for scrutiny task and finish groups (Agenda Item 9). Martyn Sargeant (Service Director for Strategy and Governance) introduced the report (an updated version was tabled at the meeting which included comments from Councillor Carolyne Culver as Chairman). He explained that it had been developed to provide a clear framework for conducting scrutiny task and finish groups and was based on the good practice guidance produced by the Centre for Governance and Scrutiny. The document, subject to any input from this meeting, would be recommended for approval at the Council meeting on 16 July 2026. Mr Sargeant advised, in response to a query from Councillor Antony Amirtharaj, that the guidance was not a legal or statutory document. Rather, it served as a good practice document which would form part of the Council’s Constitution. Councillor Richard Somner highlighted the need to be mindful when formatting documents. He stated that it was preferable to highlight amended text rather than present it in a different colour as this made it more accessible for all readers. Councillor Culver queried whether former Executive Members could participate in task and finish groups. A concern had been raised as to whether this prevented Councillors with relevant expertise from contributing on a subject. Sarah Clarke (Executive Director for Resources) responded that former Executive Members were not permitted to participate in a scrutiny review of a particular project if they were on the Executive, and therefore a decision maker, at the time that decisions were taken on the matter. This point was clarified within the Constitution. Advice could however be sought from the Monitoring Officer if clarification was needed in individual cases. Councillor Chris Read queried whether it was necessary for all scrutiny recommendations to be SMART (Specific, Measurable, Achievable, Relevant, and Timebound) and whether it was enough to say a recommendation was practical. He felt it was a task and finish group’s role to develop sensible and workable recommendations, it was then for the Executive to response to the recommendations and consider whether they were SMART. Mr Sargeant responded that this change could be recommended to Council if it was agreed by the Committee. Councillor Culver felt there was a need for flexibility. For example, setting a timeframe within a recommendation could result in it being rejected if the Executive felt this was unrealistic. Mr Sargeant clarified that ‘success metrics’ referred broadly to setting clear objectives for the review and the standards against which success would be judged. Councillor Ross Mackinnon suggested ‘success criteria’ as being more appropriate. Councillor Mackinnon then highlighted section 6 and the statement that all Members on the task group would need to be in agreement for a recommendation to be taken forward. He queried if agreement could be based on the majority view. Councillor Culver gave her agreement on this point, the task group minutes could indicate where approval had not been unanimous. Mr Sargeant felt this wording could be updated. RESOLVED that an amended version of ... view the full minutes text for item 8. |
|
|
Appointment of Task and Finish Groups To agree the terms of reference and membership for any task and finish groups that the Resources and Place Scrutiny Committee may wish to appoint to undertake in-depth scrutiny reviews. Minutes: The potential to form a task group to consider the Council’s budget setting processes was again raised. Terms of Reference had been drafted by Councillor Ross Mackinnon and these had been commented on by Councillor Carolyne Culver. Councillor Culver stated that budget scrutiny should be undertaken on an ongoing basis. The task group should concentrate its efforts with a forward look on the budget and consideration should be given to best practice employed elsewhere in budget setting. Action: · The Terms of Reference for the Council’s budget setting processes would be finalised and provided to the Committee for consideration. |
|
|
Task and Finish Group Updates To receive updates from the chairmen of task and finish groups appointed by the Resources and Place Scrutiny Committee. Minutes: This item was not discussed. |
|
|
Executive Forward Plan To advise the Committee of items to be considered by West Berkshire Council’s Executive and for Members to decide whether to review any of the proposed items prior to the meeting indicated in the Plan. Minutes: The Committee noted the Council’s Forward Plan for the period up to 31 August 2026 (Agenda Item 12). The potential to scrutinise items in advance of Executive consideration was discussed. Councillor Ross Mackinnon commented that the Forward Plan lacked detail on upcoming items making it difficult to form a view on items that could come to scrutiny. The full detail was generally not known until the Executive agenda was published and this increased the potential for items being called-in. Sarah Clarke (Executive Director for Resources) acknowledged that the level of detail could be enhanced. She also felt there was scope to tailor the document for each Scrutiny Committee. A meeting was to be arranged between Councillor Carolyne Culver, Sarah Clarke and Clare Lawrence (Executive Director for Place) to discuss potential items for the Committee’s Work Programme. Councillor Chris Read felt that this meeting should include a discussion on upcoming plans and strategies, and those in progress, for the Work Programme. An example could be the Delivery Plan for Asset Optimisation. Councillor Culver felt that discussions between Scrutiny Members and Executive Members would be beneficial. Sarah Clarke explained that this was a matter she would discuss with the Leader of the Council. Action: · Sarah Clarke would discuss, with the Leader of the Council, the potential for Scrutiny and Executive Members to meet to identify items for future scrutiny review. |
|
|
Corporate Programme To advise the Committee of the current Corporate Programme. Minutes: The Committee considered the Corporate Programme (Agenda Item 13). Following on from the discussion on the Executive Forward Plan, Members felt it would be useful for the Corporate Programme to contain further detail to help the Committee identify those projects that could be reviewed by scrutiny. Sarah Clarke agreed to take this point away for consideration. She would also advise on whether the project for the Faraday Road Football Ground would be included in the document. Action: · Sarah Clarke would seek to include further detail within the Corporate Programme. She would also advise on the Faraday Road Football Ground project. |
|
|
Resources and Place Scrutiny Committee Work Programme To receive new items and agree and prioritise the Work Programme of the Committee. Minutes: The Committee considered its Work Programme (Agenda Item 14). The arrangements for the Thames Water/Environment Agency scrutiny on 15 September 2026 were discussed. An earlier start time of 5.30pm was agreed to allow sufficient time for debate. Questions would be put to the reporting organisations in advance, but there would also be scope to ask questions at the meeting. Councillor Jeremy Cottam highlighted that clarification was needed on the ownership of the Thatcham sewage plant. The Work Programme would be discussed in more detail at the offline meeting that had already been referred to. This would include consideration of the following items: · Broadband coverage in rural areas · Business Support Review · Transformation updates · Public Protection Partnership · Faraday Road Football Ground – levels of expenditure incurred and the impact of that · Delivery Plan for Asset Optimisation |
PDF 271 KB